THE PROMISE. Fifty voters, one ballot each, and an AP commitment to publish them all after the winners were announced. The winners were announced. The ballots weren't published.
THE PROMISE. The Associated Press picks 50 voters to decide the NFL's annual awards — MVP, Coach of the Year, and the rest. Before the 2025–26 season's vote, the AP told those voters something new: after the winners were announced, the ballots would be published in full.
Then it didn't publish them. The AP announced the winners and kept the individual ballots private, and when NBC Sports asked why, the answer was that the organization had decided not to. (NBC Sports, 6 February 2026.)
WHY IT MATTERS. An award is only worth what its process is worth. Fifty people, one ballot each, no public record of who voted for whom — that's a system that runs entirely on trust, and the AP is the institution asking for it. Publishing the ballots was supposed to convert that trust into something checkable.
It's a small thing, and it's the whole thing. If the panel is deciding who gets a Coach of the Year award that can influence contract negotiations and Hall of Fame cases, the record of how they voted is the only accountability the process has.
WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED. Some voters published their own ballots anyway — the AP can control the release, not the individuals. So the public record exists in fragments: a handful of full ballots posted by journalists who decided transparency was their call, and a lot of blanks where the other forty-odd should be.
That's worse than either extreme. A partial release lets the panel be judged on the voters who chose to show their work, while the ones who didn't stay anonymous by default. The incentive runs the wrong way.
THE 2026 CONTEXT. This season the question of who votes — and whether their votes can be trusted — became a public argument again, driven by scrutiny of individual panelists rather than the process itself. That's the wrong lens. The issue isn't any one voter. It's that the AP promised a record and then declined to produce it.
The fix is boring and available: publish all fifty ballots, every year, on a fixed date. No editorial judgment required, no discretion, nothing to argue about afterward. The AP already told its voters it would do exactly that.
SPLASH'S READ: The most interesting sports-media story of the year isn't a feud or a hot mic. It's that the institution that runs the NFL's awards publicly committed to transparency and then quietly reversed it, and almost nobody noticed because there was a juicier story in the same room.
Voters are asked to be accountable for their ballots. The organization that appointed them should be held to the same standard — especially when it announced the standard itself.
Publish the fifty ballots. It costs nothing, it settles every argument about the process, and it's already what the AP told its own panel would happen.