⌕

PICKED LAST. THEN THEY KILLED THE POLL.

By Splash · November 15, 2026 · 6 min read
Arizona State Sun Devils

I was actively enrolled at Arizona State for the 2024-25 school year. Not a school I went to once, and not an alumni memory — the school I was attending while all of this happened. The Big 12’s media voters picked the Sun Devils dead last in the conference, 16th of 16. They finished 11-3, won the Big 12 championship, and played a Playoff quarterfinal on New Year’s Day. Then the conference stopped running the poll.

Why this one is mine and not just my school’s

There is a version of this story anyone can tell. “My school won a championship.” Alumni say that every year about teams they never saw play, in seasons that happened decades before or after they were on campus. It is a real thing to be proud of and it is not a claim on anything.

This is narrower than that, and that is the only reason it is worth writing. I was enrolled and active at ASU during the 2024-25 school year — the exact year a team picked 16th of 16 won the conference, made the Playoff, and got the preseason poll discontinued.

Not before. Not after. During. The school year, the season, and my enrollment are the same six months.

That is the difference between a fan and a witness, and it is the only version of this that can’t be faked. You do not have to buy a ticket to be a fan. You have to have been enrolled to have been there — and the transcript says when.

What they were coming off

2023: 3-9. Kenny Dillingham’s first season, 2-7 in the Pac-12, near the bottom of a conference that was about to stop existing. The offense averaged 17.8 points a game — tenth-worst in the country. The defense gave up 31.8. Turnover margin was minus-12, fourth-worst in FBS.

So when ASU entered a newly expanded 16-team Big 12 alongside Utah, Arizona and Colorado, the voters did the reasonable thing. They put the Sun Devils 16th. Dead last. Not “bottom half.” Sixteenth, out of sixteen.

Dillingham taped it to the wall

He printed the poll and posted it inside the team facility and left it there all offseason.

That is either the oldest coaching trick in football or the only one that has ever worked. Seventy years of bulletin boards have produced roughly one instance where the team actually did what that poll said they couldn’t — and this was it.

Then the season happened

W 48-7 Wyoming. W 30-23 Mississippi State. W 31-28 at Texas State. Then a 22-30 loss at Texas Tech — the only conference game they lost until mid-October, and the last time anybody had a comfortable afternoon against them.

W 35-31 Kansas. W 27-19 over No. 16 Utah. A 14-24 loss at Cincinnati. Then five straight: 42-21 at Oklahoma State, 35-31 UCF, 24-14 at No. 16 Kansas State, 28-23 over No. 14 BYU, and 49-7 at Arizona.

Undefeated at home. 6-0 at Mountain America Stadium, with ranked wins over Utah and BYU. 32.9 points a game. 461 points on the season.

Cam Skattebo

1,711 rushing yards. 21 rushing touchdowns. 605 receiving yards and three more scores. Fifth in the Heisman voting.

And he did it behind a redshirt freshman quarterback — Sam Leavitt, who threw for 2,885 yards, 24 touchdowns and six interceptions and ran for 443 more and five scores. Jordyn Tyson caught 1,101 yards and 10 touchdowns before a late-season injury took him out of the stretch run.

A freshman QB, a back nobody outside the Pac-12 had heard of, and a receiver who got hurt in November. That is not a roster that was supposed to win a conference.

How a four-way tie for the conference title got broken

Four teams finished 7-2 in the Big 12: Arizona State, Iowa State, BYU and Colorado. Under conference policy, a multi-team tie is resolved one seed at a time — and once a spot is locked, the tiebreaker completely resets for the teams still standing.

Step 1, head-to-head: skipped. The four had not played a round robin, and no single team had beaten all three others.

Step 2, record against common opponents. All four shared four Big 12 opponents: Kansas, Kansas State, UCF and Utah. Against that group:

Arizona State: 4-0. BYU: 3-1. Iowa State: 3-1. Colorado: 2-2.

Arizona State was seeded No. 1 in Arlington by going undefeated against the four teams all of them played.

And here is the irony nobody lead with: Kansas was in that group. ASU beat Kansas. Kansas beat both BYU and Iowa State. The team picked 16th of 16 won the tiebreaker by beating the team the two favorites lost to.

Then it reset. With ASU seeded and removed, the tiebreaker restarted from scratch for the other three — and removing ASU added Baylor to the list of common opponents, making five. All three had beaten Baylor, so: BYU 4-1, Iowa State 4-1, Colorado 3-2. Colorado was eliminated.

Step 3, highest-placed common opponent. Both had beaten Baylor, Kansas State, UCF and Utah, and both had lost to Kansas. Deadlocked.

Step 4, conference strength of schedule — the combined conference winning percentage of all nine Big 12 opponents each team faced:

Iowa State’s opponents: 36-45, a .444 winning percentage. BYU’s opponents: 31-50, .383.

Iowa State got the No. 2 seed and a trip to Arlington because the teams it played were five games better than the teams BYU played.

Arlington

45-19 over No. 16 Iowa State in the Big 12 Championship Game. First conference title since 2007.

It was dominant enough that the argument afterward wasn’t whether ASU belonged — it was whether they deserved a first-round bye over Boise State. They got one. No. 4 seed, straight to the quarterfinal.

New Year’s Day

No. 5 Texas, Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl, Atlanta. ASU lost 31-39 in double overtime.

Thirty-one to thirty-nine, in two overtimes, to a team that was five spots ahead of them in the bracket. The team picked 16th of 16 took the No. 5 seed to a second overtime on January 1.

They finished No. 7 in both the final AP and Coaches polls. From sixteenth in the conference to seventh in the country.

It wasn’t just Arizona State. The whole poll collapsed.

None of the five teams picked to finish at the top of the Big 12 finished in the top seven. That is not a bad prediction. That is an inverted one.

Every team that received a first-place vote finished with at least four conference losses and missed the championship game. All five of them:

Utah — picked 1st with 20 first-place votes — lost Cam Rising to injury and finished 2-7 in conference, tied for 13th. Kansas State — picked 2nd with 19 votes — went 5-4. Kansas — picked 4th — went 4-5. Arizona — picked 5th — went 2-7.

And Oklahoma State — picked 3rd with 14 first-place votes — went 0-9 in the Big 12 and finished dead last. Steepest fall in the conference, and it wasn’t close.

Arizona State’s climb was the biggest in the league: from 16th to tied for first. Plus fifteen.

And here is the detail that finishes it. Four teams tied at 7-2 on top of the standings — and three of them were picked 11th or worse. Iowa State was picked 6th. Colorado was picked 11th. BYU was picked 13th. Arizona State was picked 16th.

The conference’s media picked one of its four co-champions correctly and missed the other three by an average of ten places.

The part that makes it a story and not just a season

The Big 12 discontinued its preseason football media poll ahead of the 2025 season.

Read that again. A Power conference killed its own preseason poll — not because of a policy review, not because of a vote, but because the voters got it so wrong that the exercise stopped being worth printing.

Billboard material only works if the insult is credible. Once a team picked dead last wins the league, the poll stops being a prediction and becomes a liability — something a coach can tape to a wall and use for eight months. The Big 12 didn’t retire the poll because it was wrong. They retired it because being wrong had become a recruiting tool for the team they were wrong about.

SPLASH’S READ

SPLASH'S READ: I was enrolled at Arizona State for that entire season — not a season I read about afterward, and not one that happened before I got there. I was in the building while the least likely thing in college football was happening in it.

That is the whole appeal of a worst-to-first run: it comes with receipts. Nobody has to argue about whether it was a surprise. Sixteen media voters signed their names to the prediction. All the team had to do was win nine more games than they lost.

And the detail that will outlive every highlight: they broke the poll. Not the record, not the seeding — the instrument. ASU’s 2024 season is the reason the Big 12 does not print a preseason ranking anymore. That is a stranger thing to have on a résumé than a championship, and it happened to the school that was supposed to come in last.

Cinderella stories usually end with a trophy. This one ended with a conference quietly cancelling the thing that doubted them. That’s better.

Sources & claims: 2024 Big 12 Football Media Preseason Poll — Arizona State voted 16th of 16, and the conference discontinued the preseason football media poll ahead of the 2025 season. 2024 season record and results — 11-3 overall, 7-2 Big 12, Big 12 Champions, first conference title since 2007; 45-19 over No. 16 Iowa State in the Big 12 Championship Game in Arlington; No. 4 seed and first-round bye in the CFP; 39-31 double-overtime loss to No. 5 Texas in the Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl on January 1, 2025; finished No. 7 in the final AP and Coaches polls; 6-0 at home with ranked wins over No. 16 Utah and No. 14 BYU; 32.9 points per game and 461 points on the season — per ESPN, Wikipedia’s 2024 Arizona State Sun Devils football team entry, and Sports Reference, as cited in the source material for this page. Individual stats — Cam Skattebo 1,711 rushing yards / 21 rushing TD / 605 receiving yards / 3 receiving TD / fifth in Heisman voting; Sam Leavitt 2,885 passing yards / 24 TD / 6 INT / 443 rushing yards / 5 rushing TD; Jordyn Tyson 1,101 receiving yards / 10 TD; Myles Rowser 98 tackles; Javen Robinson 3 interceptions. 2023 context — 3-9 record, 17.8 points per game (10th-worst), 31.8 allowed, minus-12 turnover margin (fourth-worst in FBS) — per the same sources. Kenny Dillingham posted the preseason poll inside the team facility. Not independently verified for this page: the specific wording of any poll document, and the exact date the Big 12 announced the poll’s discontinuation. This page is written from the perspective of an ASU student who was enrolled during the 2024 season, which is stated openly rather than concealed.