⌕
← Back to the board · 🥊 Boxing

Cement In His Gloves: The Margarito Scandal That Broke Boxing's Trust

NOV 6, 2026 · SPLASH · SOURCED FROM SPORTSFORDAYS

THE CATCH: January 24, 2009, Staples Center. Antonio Margarito is minutes away from defending his WBA welterweight title against Sugar Shane Mosley when the whole house of cards comes down. Mosley's trainer, Nazim Richardson, was already suspicious of Margarito's wraps. He picked up one of the knuckle pads laid out on the wrapping table and inspected it himself. It was hard. Hard like it wasn't gauze. The commissioner got involved, and what happened next changed boxing.

"So I checked the pad and when I checked the pad, it felt hard." — Nazim Richardson

WHO MARGARITO WAS: Born March 18, 1978 in Torrance, California, raised in Tijuana, Margarito went pro at 15 years old as a welterweight because he wanted money for his family. He built the "Tijuana Tornado" reputation off a high-pressure style — walking through punches, throwing non-stop, never getting tired. He held the WBO welterweight belt for five years before losing it to Paul Williams in 2007. Then came July 26, 2008: Margarito vs. the undefeated Miguel Cotto in Las Vegas, for the WBA strap. Cotto outboxed him early, but Margarito just kept coming. By round seven Cotto was hurt and bleeding everywhere. In the 11th, Cotto took the first knockdown of his entire career, and his uncle threw in the towel. First loss, 32 fights in. After the fight, cameras caught Margarito's left hand wrap torn — and gauze doesn't rip like that.

WHAT THE PADS SAID: The material pulled from Margarito's wraps was wet, and the substance matched the profile of plaster of Paris — the same stuff used to make casts and statues. Paste when wet, rock when it dries. In a boxing glove, a fighter's own sweat turns it into a weapon as the fight goes on. The kicker: the pads looked used. Discolored, sweated through, with dried blood on them. That detail made everyone ask the obvious question — were these the same pads from the Cotto fight six months earlier? Even with all that, officials didn't disqualify Margarito. They made him rewrap under supervision and let him fight anyway.

"He was hitting Cotto with bricks."

THE FALLOUT: Days after Mosley destroyed Margarito in a ninth-round TKO, the California Department of Justice lab confirmed the substance was plaster of Paris. Margarito and his trainer Javier Capetillo went to a hearing. Capetillo's defense: he reached in his bag for knuckle pads and accidentally grabbed the plaster pads instead — which raises the question of why plaster pads were in the bag at all. Both got suspended for a year, which a lot of people called light. The last time this happened in boxing — Luis Resto and Panama Lewis against Billy Collins Jr. in 1983 — both men went to jail. Resto got two and a half years, Lewis got four. Margarito and Capetillo got a vacation.

THE MOSLEY NIGHT: Margarito entered that fight a 4.5-to-1 favorite. He left it with nothing left. The host's own words say the quiet part out loud.

"Isn't it funny how when there's no bricks in your gloves, you don't seem to apply as much pressure as you did in the past?"

THE RECEIPTS AND THE REMATCH: The suspicion never left him. Alfonso Gomez, who sparred with Margarito years earlier, said Margarito broke his nose in sparring — and that nobody ever hit him that hard. "I have never been hit so hard in my life." Then, December 3, 2011: the rematch everybody needed, Margarito vs. Cotto in New York City. Cotto never once blamed the plaster for the first loss — through all the media baiting, his answer was always the same.

"I just carry my defeat like a man the whole way." — Miguel Cotto

This time there was no question what the punches were made of. Cotto opened Margarito up early, and by round nine Margarito's surgically repaired eye socket — the one Manny Pacquiao broke — was shut. Doctors stopped the fight. Cotto's words said it all: "It's over. It's over… and revenge." Margarito never fought again. His whole career carries a question mark.

SPLASH'S READ: Plaster in the wraps ain't gamesmanship, it's a weapon, and a one-year ban for it is charity. Cotto got his face rearranged and his undefeated record took, and still never ran his mouth about it — that's a man. The 2011 rematch was the only verdict that mattered: Cotto closed Margarito's eye and ended his career, clean. Some questions don't need a court to answer — the tape tells you everything.

Sources & claims: This page reports the host's claims as their claims — video "The Boxer That Hid Cement In His Gloves" (SportsForDays, YouTube). Quotes are as read in the transcript.

📺 Watch the full video