โŒ•

HE SAYS SIX MONTHS. SHE SAYS FOUR TIMES.

NOV 21, 2026 ยท SPLASH ยท HIP-HOP ยท THE FEUD
Mariah Carey and Eminem

DID MARIAH CAREY DATE EMINEM? NOBODY HAS EVER SETTLED IT, AND BOTH OF THEM SAID IT ON THE RECORD.

He says a relationship lasted six to seven months. She says she was in his presence four times, that it wasn’t dating, and that the men she’s been intimate with fit on one hand — “and he ain’t on the hand.”

Everything else is songs. Four of them, over seven years, all charted, all dated. That’s what this page is: the record list, in order, with the one disputed fact labelled as disputed.

THE DISPUTED FACT, BOTH VERSIONS

His version, on Shade 45, 2006: “Me and Mariah did have a relationship for about a good 6-7 months, something like that.” Asked what happened: “Didn’t work. I wasn’t really into what she was into and our personalities collided.” And: “She’s a diva… but the fact that she denied, that’s bad.”

Her version, on camera, 2002: “I did not have a physical relationship with him. I did not have an intimate relationship… in terms of me having an intimate relationship with men, I can name them all on one hand and he ain’t on the hand.”

And then the number she put on it: “I hung out with him, I spoke to him on the phone. I think I was probably with him a total of four times, and I don’t consider that dating somebody.”

And in December 2002 she took it to Oprah and said the rumors weren’t true.

Six months versus four meetings. That’s the gap, and no document has ever closed it.

2001: HOW THEY GOT IN A ROOM

Both were coming off hard years.

She had just bought her way out of Sony — paying roughly $10 million for the rights to Glitter — and signed one of the biggest deals in music history at around $100 million with Virgin. Her three-year relationship with Luis Miguel had ended.

He was at the peak of a different climb: The Slim Shady LP made him a star, The Marshall Mathers LP was the biggest-selling album of 2000, and he was working on 8 Mile — while being sued for $10 million by his mother and $10 million by his wife.

The introduction, according to her former producer Damizza: Eminem called wanting her for 8 Mile. Damizza told her, she said no, then asked for his number. They got on a three-way call, and the first thing out of his mouth was: “I want you to play my mother.”

Damizza’s read: “Her insecurities kicked in. Big time… So then it was her chasing him. It wasn’t him chasing her.”

THE TARMAC

June 2001, as reported at the time: she flew her private plane to Detroit to pitch him on appearing in a Glitter video. She waited on the tarmac for four hours. He showed up, declined the video, and by every account that’s when the conversation turned personal.

Four hours on a runway is the image that outlived the relationship — and it’s the one that ended up in a lyric eighteen months later.

RECORD ONE: “SUPERMAN” (2002)

The Eminem Show, May 2002, number one, Grammy for Best Rap Album.

“Superman” names her without naming her: “What you trying to be my new wife? What you Mariah, fly through twice?” And then the tarmac line: “Just sit your drunk ass on that runway, hoe.”

He confirmed the reading himself, in his book: “Without getting into all the tabloid stuff, you can read between the lines.”

And here’s the detail that makes the whole feud make sense: according to Dina Rae, who sings on the released version, Mariah was the original vocalist on the song — her vocal was the reference, and Dina was flown to Detroit afterward to replace her. He wrote a song about her, with her on it, and then took her off it.

RECORD TWO: “CLOWN” (2002)

November 2002. 8 Mile in theaters, Eminem at the absolute peak. At the junket he said, carefully: “We had somewhat of a relationship. I’m not going to get into all the details.”

One month later, Charmbracelet, and a song for him:

“You should have never intimated we were lovers / when you know very well we never touched each other.”

That is the whole disagreement in two lines, written into a single.

And then she took it on the road. July 2003, United Center, Chicago — performing “Clown” live — a dancer came out in a blonde wig wearing Ben Wallace’s Detroit Pistons jersey, dancing on strings like a marionette, while the screen ran the routine in Eminem Show-style lettering.

When she finished, she said the thing that made it worse than a diss: “It’s all in fun. We’re just having a good time.” Which is how you put a man on a string in front of 20,000 people and call it a joke.

RECORD THREE: “OBSESSED” (2009)

Seven years later, both married or remarried, both in different lives — and he went back to it. Relapse, “Bagpipes from Baghdad,” naming her and Nick Cannon by name: “Nick Cannon better back the [hell] up.”

Cannon answered on his blog as “Miss Marshall.” Mariah went to the studio.

“Obsessed” — and the video, where she plays him as a stalker with a shrine in his bedroom, in a hoodie and a goatee, and ends it by having him hit by a bus. “Why are you so obsessed with me?”

Her best line in it isn’t the hook: “You’re mom and pop, I’m a corporation.”

RECORD FOUR: “THE WARNING” (2009)

His answer, weeks later, and the ugliest thing in the whole exchange. It opens by referencing the video (“is that supposed to be me with a goatee?”), threatens to release phone calls, and ends with audio clips of her voice.

Her response to reporters, and it is the best line of the entire feud: “Who? I don’t eat candy.”

THE NUMBERS UNDERNEATH THE FEUD

Because the argument was never only about who was in the room — it was about two careers moving in opposite directions while it happened.

The Eminem Show (2002) — the album that carried “Superman” — sold roughly 27 million copies worldwide, one of the best-selling albums ever released.

8 Mile (2002) — grossed about $242 million worldwide, and its soundtrack debuted at number one. Which is the part that stings: it was the movie she had wanted him for, and it came out the same season her own film didn’t work.

The Emancipation of Mimi (2005) — her comeback — debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 with 404,000 copies, her biggest US sales week since Daydream in 1995. Seven times platinum. Three Grammys.

Those three numbers are the whole feud in one picture: 2002 was his year, 2005 was hers, and both of them were keeping score in public while pretending not to.

And the quiet one: her self-titled debut came out in 1990; his debut, Infinite, came out in 1996. Six years apart — which is why the “who is bigger” argument underneath the whole thing was never really a question.

HOW IT ENDED

He said he was done — told Vibe he didn’t want to beat a dead horse. Cannon kept it going for years afterward, and that part has nothing to do with her.

Then, in 2020, her memoir The Meaning of Mariah Carey came out. His name is not in it.

Asked why, she gave the closing statement of a twenty-year argument: “If someone didn’t pertain to the meaning of Mariah Carey, then they’re not in the book.”

SPLASH'S READ

Read the four records in order and you notice something nobody says out loud: he kept making songs about her, and she made two.

“Superman,” “Bagpipes from Baghdad,” “The Warning,” plus the voicemail stunt on tour and the Shade 45 interview — that’s five moves on his side over seven years. She answered twice, both times better, and then stopped.

The funniest part is that both of them won the same argument. She got the last word with silence and a book that didn’t mention him. He got a hit album out of it. And the actual question — did they date — is exactly as unresolved as it was in 2002.

Six months. Four times. Both on the record. Two people who agree they were in the same room and disagree about what the room was.

AD SPACE ยท RESERVED
MORE ON THE BOARD โ–ธ
๐ŸŽค All Culture ยท Mariah’s $3M a year
Sources & claims: Sources. Built from the full video essay Mariah Carey vs Eminem: The Feud That Wouldn’t Die (Deep Dive), read end to end, and its embedded interview and reporting clips: his Shade 45 account of a “6-7 month” relationship; her on-camera denial and the “four times” figure; Damizza’s account of the three-way call and the 8 Mile approach; the June 2001 tarmac reporting; the July 2002 Rolling Stone quote; the November 2002 8 Mile junket line; Dina Rae on Mariah being the original vocalist on “Superman”; and the 2020 memoir remarks. Labelled as disputed: the nature of the relationship — his account and her denial are both stated and neither is presented as established fact. Song lyrics are quoted in short excerpt only. No video source on this page; the card is a house card. Related: Mariah’s $3 million a year and The comedy set.