THE CATALOG. Two coaches in Wausau mailed 46 million catalogs a year and built the Bible of sneaker culture. Foot Locker paid $146 million, then shut the warehouse.
SEPTEMBER 2022, WAUSAU, WISCONSIN. The Eastbay store closed without an announcement. No farewell sale. No press release. Just a sign at the entrance, three words long:
"Store permanently closed."
In the mid-1990s, the company behind that store mailed nearly 46 million catalogs in a single year. Kids circled sneakers in its pages and handed them to their parents as Christmas lists. Future professionals remember it as the Bible of their childhood.
Today there is no store, no catalog, and no warehouse. Type the name into a browser and you land on someone else's website.
IT BEGAN IN A HOSPITAL NURSERY. Art Juedes was one day old when another newborn was put in the bassinet beside him. Rick Gering was born two days apart from him, and they grew up in Wausau three houses from each other.
Both became coaches of young athletes. Between them they had sixteen years of college education and not a single business course — and one problem they could see every season: their athletes needed real performance shoes, and those shoes were hard to find in central Wisconsin.
Their view was that the shoe stores of America were failing the athletes who needed them most. So they fixed it themselves.
They licensed the name from a running shop in Milwaukee called Eastbay — which is how a company founded in the middle of Wisconsin came to carry the name of a store in another city.
In 1980, still in their twenties, they scraped together a few thousand dollars in track shoes and put the entire company inside a single vehicle. They drove central Wisconsin setting up what they called shoe clinics — small roadside fitting rooms for runners.
At the end of each stop they handed out a price list. That sheet of paper was the most important thing they gave away — because it let a customer keep shopping long after the van had pulled out of the parking lot.
IN 1983 THE PRICE LIST BECAME A FOUR-COLOR CATALOG. Track shoes, basketball shoes, football cleats, baseball spikes — and it did something no store in Wausau could do: it traveled.
A kid in a town with no specialty shop could see the same shoes a college athlete wore, read what each one was built for, and order a pair without leaving home.
1989: a team sales division to outfit whole high school and college squads. 1990: its first in-house team catalog and its own clothing line. By then the call center, shipping department and creative staff filled nearly an entire city block in Wausau.
The real power wasn't in the orders. It was in the waiting. Every few weeks a new catalog arrived, thick and glossy, and in households across the country it was an event. Kids carried it to school and folded down corners.
Before the internet, before message boards and release apps, there were almost no other places a young athlete could see every new sneaker in one place.
P.J. Tucker — later one of the most famous sneaker collectors in the NBA — first saw a catalog when a friend brought one to AAU practice. He called it his Bible. Sue Bird waited each month for it to land in her parents' mailbox. DeMar DeRozan: "Eastbay was my whole childhood."
AND THEN IT GOT BIG ENOUGH TO SELL.
In the years leading up to mid-1996, Eastbay's active customer accounts grew more than fourfold — from about 1.3 million names to 5.4 million — and yearly sales nearly tripled, from about $40 million to more than $117 million.
On September 29, 1995, Eastbay began trading on Nasdaq.
Three months later, Woolworth came for it. The deal was valued at up to $146 million — and on January 30, 1997, Eastbay stopped belonging to the two men who built it. The partners had a contract to keep working with the company through June 1999. They retired on June 30, 1999.
Woolworth's athletic business became Foot Locker Incorporated in 2001 — a company built entirely around athletic shoes and apparel.
HERE'S THE IRONY THAT KILLED IT. In March 1998, Eastbay turned its website into a working online store — early, and well. The company had already built the thing that would replace catalogs, and it owned it.
But a retail site is a store, not a discovery engine. The catalog's job was to arrive unasked, show you everything, and make you want something you didn't know existed. A search box only finds what you already thought to type.
When the internet moved discovery to message boards, sneaker blogs and eventually release apps, Eastbay kept the checkout and lost the audience.
THE END CAME IN STAGES, AND MOST OF THEM WERE FOOT LOCKER'S PROBLEMS.
2019: Foot Locker decided its structure no longer made sense. February 2022: the 500,000-square-foot distribution center in Wausau changed hands.
October 19, 2022: workers were told distribution would be phased out beginning January 31, 2023. 210 jobs, with the first 162 gone by the end of January. On or about April 30, 2023, the Wausau distribution center closed for good.
Nike pulling back from wholesale partners is part of what set those cuts in motion — the same retreat that gutted Foot Locker's own store economics.
And the parent company didn't survive intact either. On September 8, 2025, Dick's Sporting Goods completed its acquisition of Foot Locker in a $2.4 billion deal.
SPLASH'S READ: Eastbay wasn't killed by the internet. It was killed by being a catalog inside a mall company.
The catalog was the algorithm — a curated, seasonal, undeniable drop of everything new, arriving at your house whether you asked for it or not. Nobody has replaced that. The modern version is an infinite feed you have to hunt through, and the hunt is the business model.
Foot Locker paid $146 million for the Bible and then closed the church.
Two coaches with sixteen years of college and no business courses understood the product better than the $2.4 billion company that bought it. They were selling access. Everyone who bought the company thought they were selling shoes.