⌕

THE VETO — GRIFFEY DEMANDED OUT, THEN REFUSED THE METS

NOV 9, 2026 · SPLASH · SOURCED FROM SECRET BASE · CLAIMS AS CLAIMS
Ken Griffey Jr. — the 1999 trade demand

THE DEMAND. Autumn 1999. Ken Griffey Jr. — the best player in baseball, the reason people in the Pacific Northwest watched — told the Mariners he wanted to be traded.

Not for money. For geography. His kids were reaching school age, and the family was rooted in Orlando. Late in the '99 season he'd tried the back-and-forth life and found it unbearable.

Then two deaths in a matter of days made the decision for him: his neighbor Payne Stewart, killed in a plane crash in October, and Walter Payton, gone from a rare cancer days later. Both men were in their forties. Griffey was entering his thirties, thousands of miles from his wife and children, and did the math.

He would not extend in Seattle for any amount. The Mariners decided a trade was better than losing him to free agency the following winter.

THE LEVERAGE. As a ten-year veteran with five years in one place, Griffey had a full no-trade clause. So he handed Seattle a list of four National League teams — all of them, if not next door to Orlando, at least a shorter flight than Seattle.

THE REDS SAY NO — TO POKEY REESE. Cincinnati was the obvious fit: he'd gone to high school in Cincinnati, and it was close to home. The talks died over one player. The Reds would not include Pokey Reese, not even for Ken Griffey Jr. Reese himself reportedly said he'd have traded himself for Griffey.

THE METS SAY YES — AND GRIFFEY SAYS NO. On to New York, the fourth name on the list. GM Steve Phillips got to work, and within 48 hours the Mariners called Griffey's agent: we have a deal. LaGuardia is a quick flight to Orlando. It's exactly what he wanted.

He said no. And then he narrowed his list from four teams to one: Cincinnati, or nowhere.

THE TRADE. February 10, 2000: Griffey to the Reds for Mike Cameron, Brett Tomko, Antonio Pérez and Jake Meyer.

THE PUNCHLINE. The team that lost him got better immediately — Seattle won 116 games in 2001, tying the major-league record, though the credit belongs more to Ichiro Suzuki than to the return package. The Mets, who thought they had a deal and got rejected, won the 2000 NL wild card and went to the World Series.

And Cincinnati got the hometown superstar, the 600th home run and the injuries.

SPLASH'S READ: This is what player empowerment looked like before anyone called it that.

Griffey had a no-trade clause and used it like a weapon — not to extract money, but to choose a city and a life. He rejected a deal that was already agreed, in public, and the Mariners had to go back and take the only offer left. Front offices call that being held hostage. Players call it a contract.

The baseball irony is that the franchise he left immediately had its best season ever, and the team he refused to join went to the World Series. The reason he wanted out wasn't winning — it was being a father in the same time zone. He got exactly what he asked for, which is rarer in sports than any of the numbers.

Twenty-five years later, superstars demand trades every summer. Almost none of them get to pick the destination this cleanly. Griffey did it with a list of four and a single word: no.

Sources & claims: Secret Base, "BIG DEAL: What do you do when a legend demands a trade?" The Feb. 10, 2000 trade return (Cameron, Tomko, Pérez, Meyer) cross-checked against the Baseball Hall of Fame and Baseball Prospectus accounts.
Watch: When a legend demands a trade ↗