⌕

HE PUT A PRICE ON HIS OWN REGRET: "MINIMUM $100 MILLION."

NOV 20, 2026 · SPLASH · BUSINESS · THE EXIT
Prime Hydration and Logan Paul

IN 2026, LOGAN PAUL PUT A PRICE ON HIS OWN REGRET. Asked on the PBD podcast what it cost him not to sell Prime Hydration, he said it without hesitating: “Minimum $100 million… Don't be afraid to take chips off the table.”

Three years earlier, in Sydney, he and KSI were on the radio saying they would “probably buy Coke.”

The gap between those two interviews is the whole story of the brand.

THE NUMBERS HE SAID OUT LOUD

Prime's whole pitch was scale, and the founders sold it on the record.

2023, Sydney radio: asked what Prime would be worth in a year, KSI said “over a billion.”

The same interview gave the business plan in one sentence. When would they cash out? “The honest answer: when we both hit that beat, I'm out.”

And a marketing budget: “We have a 0 marketing budget.” Which was funny, given Prime was paying to be the official drink of the UFC, Barcelona, Arsenal and the Dodgers.

Then there's the slip. On a podcast, Logan corrected himself mid-sentence on his own sales: “In year one we cleared $110 million in retail sales… $250 million in retail sales. Sorry, that was a little mistake.”

On Aiden Ross's stream he was more careful, and probably more accurate than he intended: “We're not [loaded]. We're paper loaded.” He put the sale value at between $1.5 and $2 billion.

On the True Jordy podcast he went to $5 billion within three years — then explained, on a different podcast, that turning down $5 billion would be easy because “money becomes a bit marginal.”

THE NUMBERS THAT WERE REAL

November 2023: Bloomberg reported Prime was on track for more than $1 billion in yearly sales.

March 2024: shoppers found bottles marked down to 31p in Tesco. NIQ data had year-on-year sales down over 50%.

Prime UK, from Companies House filings: turnover around £112 million in 2023, under £33 million in 2024 — a fall of roughly 70% — with pre-tax profit down 92% to about £367,000. The company announced the days of hyper-growth were over and launched a “strategic review.”

US: sales reportedly fell roughly 40% in the first half of 2024, with 2025 revenue projected around $300 million — against the $1.2 billion the brand was being valued on.

$1.2 billion to $300 million in about two years. That is the number the podcast regret is calculated against.

WHAT THE PRODUCT ACTUALLY WAS

The reviews were brutal and they were specific, which is why they travelled.

Gordon Ramsay, handed a bottle: “...swallowing perfume.”

xQc, who does not do product reviews: “I hated all of them… it feels like a non-tasting whatever with an aftertaste.”

A creator breakdown of the formula put it plainly: it is “not an actual electrolyte formula” but “a potassium drink with sucralose.”

And the comparison stunt didn't survive contact: Prime sticks at 871 mg of electrolytes against Liquid I.V.'s 870 mg — a 1 mg gap used as a marketing point, which a nutrition reviewer called out because the composition is what matters, not the total.

THE COURTROOMS

Ryan Garcia, May 2024: Prime sued him for defamation over posts claiming the drink contained cyanide and poison. Garcia apologised by the end of that month.

The US Olympic and Paralympic Committee: sued over Prime bottles carrying Olympic marks that Prime had not licensed — it paid Kevin Durant, not the Olympics. It settled quietly.

The PFAS class action, filed August 2023 over “forever chemicals”: Logan's defence was that the claim concerned the bottle, not the liquid, and that Prime uses the same PET suppliers as Coke and Pepsi. Most claims were thrown out in September 2024, with another going Prime's way in September 2025.

Messi's Más+: Prime's lawyers called it a copy of their bottle and colours; Más+ filed first in October 2024, making Prime's move a countersuit. In January 2026 both sides agreed to drop their claims — dismissed with no ruling for anybody.

The suppliers: Refresco, which built an entire bottling line for Prime, sued for at least $67 million in August 2024, saying the line was ready in March 2024 and Prime walked away before the final trial run without ordering a single bottle. A coconut-water supplier, Agraana, sued for about $13 million in July 2025.

And in 2026, a federal judge in a Kentucky case ordered the company to search Logan's and KSI's phones and email accounts for evidence. That is not a verdict — but it means the other side's lawyers may get to read what the two of them were texting while the drink was selling out.

THE DISTRIBUTOR

July 2026: Congo Brands Australia — the company that sold Prime in Australia — entered voluntary administration, after reporting a sharp fall in revenue and substantial inventory writedowns.

Filings showed it owed close to A$8 million and had about A$85,000 in cash.

That is less than Prime used to sell in a single hour at its peak.

THE EXIT

Here is the part that makes this a money story rather than a drinks review.

On PBD in September 2026, Logan said the company had opportunities to exit or bring in partners — and that it didn't happen because his partners didn't want it.

“Minimum $100 million. Massive mistake. Not a decision that I supported or wanted… We were like, 'yeah, we trust you guys.' And we paid the price for it.”

“Don't be afraid to take chips off the table.”

And in the same interview he was asked about the “Prime is dead” videos. He called it “completely untrue” and said “if I told you the sales we were doing, you'd be shocked.”

He didn't say what those sales were. In February 2023 he couldn't wait to read a number out loud on live radio. In 2026 he wouldn't give a ballpark — while explaining what the missed exit cost.

SPLASH'S READ

Prime did something genuinely hard: a drinks brand with two YouTubers went from zero to over a billion in revenue and put bottles in Tesco, Walmart and Barcelona. That part was real.

But there is a difference between a valuation and a cheque, and the whole collapse lives in that gap. He called himself “paper loaded” in 2023 — the most honest phrase in the story — and then, on other podcasts, quoted himself $1.5 billion, $5 billion, and a $100 million regret, all in the same breath as the plan.

A brand is worth what someone pays for it on a day they can pay. When the 31p stickers went on, the number stopped being an opinion and became a price.

Which is the same lesson as American Dream's $5 billion and CoreWeave's one customer: the moment you need the money is the moment the valuation stops being yours.

He built the thing. He just never took chips off the table.

AD SPACE · RESERVED
MORE ON THE BOARD ▸
💼 All Business · The $5 Billion Mall
Sources & claims: Sources. The founders' own claims: Logan Paul's $110 million / $250 million retail sales slip and KSI's “over a billion” valuation in the 2023 Sydney radio interview; Paul's “we're paper loaded” remark and his $1.5–$2 billion estimate on Aiden Ross's stream; the $5 billion figure on the True Jordy podcast; and his claim of a “0 marketing budget” alongside Prime's official partnerships with the UFC, FC Barcelona, Arsenal and the Dodgers. The PBD podcast interview of September 2026, in which he called the “Prime is dead” talk “completely untrue”, declined to give sales figures, and put the cost of not exiting at “minimum $100 million” with the advice “don't be afraid to take chips off the table”, is as broadcast. Market data: Bloomberg, November 2023, reporting Prime on track for more than $1 billion in annual sales; NIQ data showing year-on-year sales down more than 50% entering 2024; bottles marked down to 31p at Tesco in March/April 2024; Prime Hydration UK accounts filed at Companies House showing turnover of roughly £112 million in 2023 falling to about £33 million in 2024, with pre-tax profit down 92% to around £367,000 and a “strategic review” announced (June 2025); US sales reportedly down roughly 40% in the first half of 2024 with 2025 revenue projected near $300 million against a $1.2 billion valuation. Litigation: Prime's defamation suit against Ryan Garcia (May 2024), which Garcia apologised over; the US Olympic and Paralympic Committee action over unlicensed Olympic marks, which settled; the PFAS class action (August 2023) in which most claims were dismissed in September 2024 and a further claim resolved in Prime's favour in September 2025, with Paul's “it's the bottle, not the liquid” explanation as quoted; Prime's dispute with Messi's Más+, where Más+ filed first in October 2024 and both sides dropped their claims in January 2026; Refresco's suit for at least $67 million (August 2024) over a bottling line Prime allegedly abandoned before the final trial run; and Agraana's roughly $13 million claim (July 2025). The 2026 Kentucky order requiring the company to search Logan Paul's and KSI's phones and email accounts is a discovery ruling, not a finding of liability. Distribution: Congo Brands Australia entered voluntary administration in July 2026 (ASIC notice; administrator's first meeting), owing close to A$8 million with about A$85,000 in cash. Product criticism quoted from Gordon Ramsay's interview, xQc's stream, and nutrition-creator breakdowns, with the electrolyte comparison (871 mg vs 870 mg) as stated on camera. Video source: UnderLens, “Remember Prime? Now Logan Paul Blames Everyone Else...” (pkECudcApxk) — read in full; every figure above checked against the reporting named here. Related: the $5 billion mall and CoreWeave.