Twenty-five years after the show ended, the cast of In Living Color reunited at Tribeca in 2019 — Keenen Ivory Wayans, Shawn Wayans, Kim Wayans, Tommy Davidson and David Alan Grier — after a screening of the pilot, moderated by the New York Times’ Aisha Harris.
What the show was, in one sentence
Five seasons in the early ’90s, premiering in 1990. It launched Jim Carrey, Jamie Foxx and Jennifer Lopez.
Grier put the gap it filled this way: there was a long-running idea that somebody should do a black “SNL,” — a black sketch show from a Black point of view — and “Keenen was the one who actually did it.”
He called joining it “the best decision of my life,” and explained why in a way that lands: he came out of the Yale School of Drama, trained for repertory company work, and “this is the closest I ever came to a repertory company.”
Tommy Davidson’s version of Keenen is the best line of the panel:
“He reminds me of Professor X from X-Men. He took all of us mutants together and told us, ‘Use your powers.’”
The theme song was a real sentence
Near the end of the panel, prompted by his brother, Keenen recalled the first meeting with Fox where the idea of a series came up.
“I said, ‘I don’t want to do TV, I want to do movies.’ And they said, ‘You can do what you want to do.’”
That is the opening line of the theme song. A television executive said it in a pitch meeting and it became the hook of the most recognizable intro of the decade.
Which tells you something about how culture actually gets made. Not from a creative brief. From somebody in a room saying the obvious thing in a way that happened to rhyme.
How the room worked
Keenen on the writing: “Standup was our background, so sketches were the first writing we ever did” — and the show was a different animal, “more intent behind it, more in your face, and the energy of it was a little bit different.”
“It was very competitive, but fun competitive. There was never a small player in any sketch. Everybody was going for it.”
Davidson on the anticipation before it aired:
“It was like a steam pot about to blow, because it built up. We knew what it was gonna do. All the energy was anticipation because America needed something new, and In Living Color was the thing.”
The one that got argued about in the room
“Men on…” — Grier and Damon Wayans as two gay cultural critics reviewing film and television — was hugely popular and also the sketch that drew real criticism.
Spike Lee objected. Grier:
“People would get upset, like Spike would say, ‘Man, that’s not what it’s about.’”
Asked whether it could be made today, Grier said flatly: “I don’t think you can.” His reasoning: “I have evolved from then. But back then, I would say there was never any malice in our portrayal of these gay men, at least from my perspective at that time. But it was very much of its time.”
And the observation that makes it more interesting than a simple apology:
“The younger gay community endorsed us, and the older, more conservative community was like, ‘You don’t talk about that.’”
Keenen disagreed with him. “I think that the sketch could be done today. I think that we have more information about gay culture, so maybe we could make it even funnier… the whole intent of the show was to include everybody.” He added the fair caveat: “You can only be as good as the time period that you live in with the information that you have.”
Two men who made the same sketch, thirty years later, disagreeing about whether it was wrong. That is a much better conversation than the one the internet usually has about old comedy.
SPLASH’S READ
SPLASH'S READ: The theme song fact is the whole page. A Fox executive said “you can do what you want to do” to a man who had just said he did not want to be there — and that sentence became the promise the entire show was built on.
Because that is what In Living Color actually was: a show that a network did not control. Keenen ran it, the cast competed inside it, and it produced Carrey, Foxx and Lopez out of the same five-season window. Nobody designs that. You permit it.
And the Men on Film argument is the honest version of a hard question. Grier says he has evolved and does not think it could be made now. Keenen says it could, funnier. Both of them are describing the same sketch and neither is lying.
The thing worth keeping is that they were willing to have the argument in public, on a stage, about their own work. Most reunions are nostalgia. This one was a post-mortem.