THE STATISTIC THAT EXPLAINS EVERYTHING. Half of American men under 50 now have an active online sportsbook account. Ninety percent of that money is bet online — roughly $100 billion. In 2017, before the Supreme Court struck down the federal ban, Americans wagered five or six billion dollars on sports in a year. Last year it was past $150 billion.
The New Yorker's case study for what that does to a person is Jontay Porter — a backup forward who, in April 2024, became the first NBA player banned for life over gambling. He has since pleaded guilty to wire fraud and may go to prison.
THE FAMILY. In Columbia, Missouri, the Porters were unicorns: eight kids, all of them with college basketball scholarships. The stars were Michael and Jontay. They went to Missouri together; Michael left after his freshman year for the NBA. Jontay blew out his knee, went undrafted after being projected as a top pick, and had finally started to trust basketball when basketball betrayed him.
March 2020: the Memphis Grizzlies took a chance, roughly $2 million. Add an insurance settlement of about $2.5 million and he's 19 with roughly $4.5 million — which becomes the gambling fund. His stated goal was "NBA f— you money" without relying on basketball. So he started day trading and playing illegal online casinos, then got cut, and stopped worrying about how it looked.
THE FIRST BET. Chiefs-Ravens, Sunday night. He put roughly $125,000 on Kansas City. The Chiefs were winning big; Lamar Jackson scored; Baltimore came back and won 36-35. He lost the bet, deleted the app, suspended his account that night — and came back the next morning for revenge.
"That was my first big loss that just wrecked me. And then the next morning I was mad. I came back for revenge."
When the reporters went through his betting data, he'd made something like 150 bets for over a million dollars in that same weekend. He'd memory-holed it.
THE MACHINE. What made him valuable to a sportsbook wasn't luck. It was volume, and the industry has a system for volume: VIP hosts — employees whose job is to find the customers losing the most money and keep them betting. Sportsbooks don't extend credit, so they aren't required to check income or assets the way a Vegas casino might. A Taco Bell manager who bets enough gets the same perks as a whale.
Porter's host at FanDuel was Frank Cardenas. During a three-day stretch — much of it Russian table tennis in the middle of the night, which is the fastest-moving market there is — Porter won over a million, and Cardenas gave him a $10,000 bonus. Then he asked for another. Cardenas, an experienced host, knew the type: a guy betting everything was going to give it back.
He did. Over roughly 18 months Porter bet about $50 million on FanDuel alone, after more than $30 million earlier. As he told the reporters: Frank became the reason I stayed.
THE SPIRAL. He ran out of liquid money and wouldn't admit there was a problem. His family intervened twice; his fiancée, a financial adviser, threatened to leave. But he was also rebuilding his career, so nobody wanted the story out.
January 2024: the Raptors called him up. His family thought the worst was over. What they didn't know: he had a couple hundred thousand dollars in gambling debts to bookies who let him bet on credit, and he was days or weeks from a multi-year NBA contract.
THE RIG. With a bookie he was close to — Ammar Awad — the plan was to manipulate prop bets on his own stats. Each side blames the other for the idea. The mechanics: spread bets across sportsbooks so no single book's monitors trip, let the bookies profit, and wipe his debt.
January 26, 2024: he played a couple of minutes, then came out pointing at his eye. He hadn't scored. The unders on his stat lines all hit — and per DraftKings' own email to customers the next day, the most profitable bet of the night was the Jontay Porter unders.
An integrity monitor flagged it immediately. Of every bet available across every sport that night, a reserve forward for Toronto was the single most profitable position on the board. That is not a coincidence, it's a confession.
He swore he'd never do it again. Then Awad came back: they hadn't gotten enough down because of limits. Pressure, pressure, pressure. And on the night he played the best game of his career against his brother's Denver team, his fiancée told him in the hotel room she was pregnant.
That was the trigger. He'd rig it one more time — on one condition: his friend Mahmoud would go with Awad and the bookies.
March 20, 2024. Mahmoud walked into a DraftKings casino with a duffel bag of cash and handed it across the counter, into his own account. Then they placed an $80,000 parlay. An $80,000 bet on LeBron James raises an eyebrow. An $80,000 bet on Jontay Porter might as well have come with a signed statement.
THE END. The investigation broke March 25 — five days later. The NBA issued a lifetime ban. Within days, FanDuel emailed him an offer to reactivate his account.
That detail is the story's coldest line: the integrity department and the retention department are the same company.
What followed was the part that doesn't get clipped. He went to a gun range a few times to blow off steam. Once, he held the gun to his head and cried.
"The only thing holding me to this earth right now is my faith in God and my unborn son. I have to meet him."
Gambling addiction carries the highest suicide rate of any addiction, in part because it leaves no physical symptoms — by the time anyone sees it, it's often too late.
He confessed to everything, and the case turned out to be bigger than him: a conspiracy that also swept in Chauncey Billups, Damon Jones and Terry Rozier. Those are charges, not convictions.
WHAT HE SAYS NOW. He's playing semi-pro basketball in Seattle, mostly a stay-at-home dad, finishing his degree, with a second son on the way. And he says something almost nobody in his position says:
"I'm glad all that stuff happened... If I didn't lose my NBA job, I would have lost my wife and I would have lost my family's support. I might have even lost my life."
He doesn't blame FanDuel. He pleaded guilty to wire fraud because, in his framing, he tried to rob the casino that had robbed him first.
SPLASH'S READ: The moral of this story isn't that a desperate man broke the rules. It's that the product was built to find him.
Porter had a gambling problem before the apps existed — illegal casinos, day trading, the same dopamine loop. What the legal market added was scale: a $50 million handle, a personal host, bonuses for winning, and no affordability check because a sportsbook isn't a bank. Half of American men under 50 now carry one of these accounts. The question the industry answers with a slogan — make every moment more — is the same question a slot machine answers with a lever.
The structural point is in those two emails. A company can flag a player's bets as a integrity threat on Tuesday and offer to reactivate his account on Friday, because one department protects the game and the other protects the revenue, and nobody in the building is responsible for the person.
Porter did the one thing the system can't tolerate: he treated the sportsbook the way the sportsbook treats its customers. That's why he's banned for life and the app is still on your phone.