THE TWO NUMBERS. In 2025 PepsiCo paid nearly $2 billion upfront for a soda brand that started in a Texas kitchen. That's the number everyone remembers.
The second number is the interesting one: $300 million, all or nothing, payable only if Poppi hit performance targets by the third quarter of 2027. Miss them and PepsiCo pays nothing. And because of how acquisitions are accounted for, PepsiCo has to tell investors every quarter what it thinks that promise is worth.
So there is a running, public estimate of PepsiCo's own confidence in the deal. Here's what it did:
| WHEN | PEPSICO'S VALUATION OF THE $300M EARNOUT |
| May 2025 (deal closes) | $180 million |
| End of 2025 | $278 million |
| March 2026 | $162 million |
| June 2026 | $117 million |
| October 2026 | $12 million |
That last quarter is the one that doesn't add up at first — because in that same quarter PepsiCo said Poppi had double-digit volume growth and gained share. Growing again isn't the same as growing enough. The estimate says PepsiCo now sees very little chance of Poppi clearing the bar by 2027.
THE ORIGIN. Allison Ellsworth was drinking apple cider vinegar daily — liked how it made her feel, hated the taste. She and her husband Stephen turned it into a sparkling vinegar soda called Mother, sold in glass bottles at a farmers market.
2018: Shark Tank. Most of the sharks passed. Rohan Oza put in $400,000 and was blunt about what was wrong: incredible founder story, incredible liquid, your branding is crap.
So they rebuilt it. Glass bottle became a bright 12-ounce can, and Mother became Poppi. That change mattered more than it looked: Mother was a health drink that lived next to the kombucha. Poppi was a soda you could feel a little better about drinking.
It launched in March 2020 — the first week of COVID, with stores in chaos and events canceled. So Allison went where almost no beverage brand was taking seriously yet: TikTok. Recipes, trends, her own story. The bright cans looked great on camera, and creators kept posting them. By 2023, Poppi had passed $100 million in sales.
WHAT PEPSICO DIDN'T HAVE. Being famous online doesn't get you on every shelf. Distribution is unglamorous: trucks, warehouses, sales teams, someone convincing thousands of store managers to keep giving you space. Allison has said Poppi was shut out of stadiums, music venues and the biggest chains.
PepsiCo had the opposite problem. It could put a drink almost anywhere in America; what it lacked was a drink younger shoppers were excited about. In 2023 Beverage Digest reported Dr Pepper had pulled even with Pepsi in US soda volume, and growth in the aisle was moving toward things that felt better for you. Coca-Cola saw the same shift and built Simply Pop.
PepsiCo had approached once before and it hadn't felt right. This time it did. Allison says the offer came on a Sunday and they said yes by Tuesday — and she's been open about why: they knew they had to sell. 44 employees became millionaires.
WHAT THEY ACTUALLY BOUGHT. Not the cans, the followers or the $100 million in sales — Poppi already had those. PepsiCo paid for what Poppi might become with PepsiCo's system behind it. That future is exactly what the $300 million was designed to reward.
THE HANDOFF. That's also the hardest part. A brand handled by one distributor gets handed to new trucks, new warehouses and new sales reps who already carry hundreds of products. Orders get missed. Shelves sit empty. A brand moving fast loses its rhythm.
By July 2026, CEO Ramon Laguarta was explaining that moving Poppi onto PepsiCo's system
“had a bit of an impact on the brand in the first half of the year,”
and said it was resolved. Beverage Digest reported Poppi's US sales declined over those six months in both volume and dollars — and pointed at something else too: a flood of new gut-soda competitors.
THE CATEGORY POPPI BUILT. When Poppi launched, gut-health soda was a corner of the aisle: about $197 million in US sales in 2020, per Euromonitor, and about $440 million by 2024. Small next to regular soda — big enough that everyone wanted in.
Olipop was already there: in February 2025, a month before the Poppi deal, it raised at a $1.85 billion valuation after roughly doubling sales to about $400 million. That same month Coca-Cola launched Simply Pop with 6 grams of prebiotic fiber — roughly triple Poppi's.
Then the competitor from inside the house. In July 2025, two months after closing Poppi, PepsiCo announced Pepsi Prebiotic Cola — online that fall, store shelves early 2026, in the same months Poppi's sales were falling. PepsiCo's line: there's room for both because they serve different consumers. There's no public data showing the cola took Poppi's sales, but the filing shows PepsiCo wasn't counting on Poppi alone.
THE AWKWARD PART. After the sale, PepsiCo ran most of what drives Poppi's numbers: distribution, marketing budget, the sales teams pitching retailers. And any earnout payment would come out of PepsiCo's own pocket. That's not evidence PepsiCo held the brand back — it says it's investing more — but it is a reminder of who holds the levers when the target gets measured.
SPLASH'S READ: This is the cleanest lesson in earnouts anyone has published this year, and it costs nothing to read.
Poppi didn't lose 96 percent of its value. Nobody lost $266 million, because that money was never paid — it was always a maybe. What collapsed is PepsiCo's forecast, and the filing says that forecast moves with its own projections for Poppi's revenue and margins.
That's the trap in every founder earnout. The buyer takes control of the levers — trucks, reps, shelf space, ad budget — and then measures you against a number you can no longer pull. Sometimes that's sabotage. Usually it's just physics: a startup's growth curve is a function of scarcity and hustle, and neither survives integration.
The Ellsworths got paid for what Poppi was. PepsiCo paid for what it might become. The gap between those two things is now priced at $12 million on a public balance sheet, and it has to be resolved by September 2027.
Meanwhile the founders have moved on — Allison and Stephen are launching a new brand, Jetti. They took the cash. PepsiCo took the risk. That's the deal.