THE SIX. Victor Wembanyama hung 52 points and 24 rebounds — both career highs — with eight blocks, and San Antonio survived Dallas 112-111 on a Kyrie Irving miss with three seconds left. Live from USC, Stephen A. Smith asked Skip to grade the night, one to ten. Skip's answer stopped the room:
Just because the numbers are historic, I'll go six.
THE DEGREE OF DIFFICULTY. Skip's case starts with who wasn't on the floor for Dallas. The Mavs' center was Daniel Gafford — listed 6-10, and Skip says he doesn't buy the listing. His scale for the night:
What was the degree of difficulty last night against the Dallas Mavericks? Scale of one to 10. It was a one.
The matchup math, per Skip: Gafford gives up seven inches to Wembanyama, the Mavs' next-tallest player is Cooper Flagg at 6-9, and it showed — all seven of Wemby's first-half buckets were dunks, and a career-high 23 free throws (19 made) came because Dallas had no way to contest him in the paint. And still, Skip says, the Spurs blew a 19-point lead and lost the second half 60-44.
THE THREE. The objection isn't the 52. It's the 1-for-8 from three, and what it says about how San Antonio plays:
That's my biggest issue with him. They go as he goes from three.
Skip's receipts from the closing stretch: down three with five minutes left, and Wembanyama missed three free throws down the stretch. His read on the night: the numbers were historic, and the game was still one Kyrie jumper away from a loss.
THE PLAYOFF FILE. Skip brought last spring to the table. Wembanyama's best playoff game, per Skip, was Game 1 at Oklahoma City, where he scored 12 points in the restricted area — then averaged four a night there over the next 11 playoff games, "because he wants to play like a two guard at 7 ft 5." Then the three-point split: in the playoff games Wembanyama shot 47% from three, San Antonio won all 12; in their 10 losses, he shot 21%:
They're living and dying by his three-point shot, and they almost died last night.
THE FINALS FILE. The deeper file is the Finals — Skip's Knicks beat San Antonio in five, and Skip has the fourth quarters memorized: 12-for-35 (34%), 2-of-8 from three, 13-of-18 at the line:
Every game down the stretch he disappeared. He disappeared. He showed no early clutch gene.
And his problem with the coronation machine: the GM poll opened the season all-Wemby for MVP, the building chanted it last night — "I don't see dominating on the offensive end. I don't see unbeatable in big playoff games."
THE PEOPLE, WAKE UP. The money line came with a stat sheet. Opening night against a healthy Thunder: 1-for-13 and 0-for-4 from three. Then at Utah: 12 points, 11 boards, 5-of-15 from the floor, 0-for-5 from deep:
People, wake up. It comes and it goes. If it's Daniel Gafford, you got me.
Stephen A. called it blasphemy on the spot — 7:00 A.M. West Coast time, opening segment, and Skip was already starting trouble. Skip, for his part, warned Stephen A. he was going to lose his presidential vote before the show was over. Stephen A.'s reply: "I approve that message."
THE OTHER SIDE. Stephen A.'s counter ran the whole arsenal: the man is 7-5, the reigning Defensive Player of the Year, and defense is half the sport — eight blocks are eight blocks, even if three of them came on one possession. Skip's line on the night: "He should have scored 100. He should have gone for 200." Per Stephen A., that's the tell: Skip would have called him selfish for doing exactly that. The forward-looking part they actually agreed on — nine or ten Defensive Player of the Year trophies are in play, and Skip's exact words were "Okay, I buy that. I agree." Stephen A. puts Wembanyama at a minimum of three championships. The closer went to the debate itself: Stephen A. let Skip's last word run long because "he had something profound to say" — Skip's answer on what that profound point was: "to win the debate," with Stephen A. finishing the thought: "agreeing with me."
SPLASH'S READ: The box score says 52, 24, and eight. Skip says read the fine print. Both can be true — that's why this debate never dies.
Skip's six has a tell: the standard moves. Score 100, he wants 200. Block eight, three don't count. There is no stat line against Daniel Gafford that moves Skip Bayless, because his real case was never about last night. It's the 1-for-8, the 34% in the Finals' fourth quarters, the Spurs living and dying by the three. That file is fat, and it's real.
Here's where Stephen A. is right: none of it is a verdict. It's year three. The defense is already all-time, the thin-frame talk is tired, and the reigning Defensive Player of the Year just put up 52 and 24 while the host predicts three rings. Skip never said bust. He said the crown is early.
Which is either the bravest thing said on sports TV this week, or the most Skip Bayless thing ever said. On this show, those have always been the same move.