⌕

37 BILLION STREAMS. THE COURT SAID NOBODY OWED HIM ANYTHING.

By Splash · November 14, 2026 · 7 min read
The streaming royalty pool and fake play counts

The number in the complaint was 37,000,000,000. If even a modest share of Drake’s Spotify streams over four years were generated by bots — and the filing alleged a “substantial, non-trivial percentage” of them were — then every other rights holder on the platform had been paid less than they were owed. The estimate attached to that claim was at least $600 million diverted away from artists. A federal judge dismissed the case. Then she dismissed it again, permanently.

Who sued, and what he alleged

Eric Dwayne Collins is the West Coast rapper RBX — Snoop Dogg’s cousin, part of the Death Row era. In November 2025 he filed a proposed class action in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, on behalf of US rights holders whose music sits on Spotify. Two claims: negligence, and violation of California’s Unfair Competition Law.

The theory rested on how streaming actually pays. Subscription and advertising revenue in each market is pooled monthly, then divided according to each track’s share of streams in that market. The pool is a fixed pot. So a fake stream doesn’t just pay a fraudster — it takes a fraction of a cent away from every real rights holder on the platform, and none of them can see it happening.

His central example was Drake, described in the complaint as the most-streamed artist of all time. Drake was not a defendant. He was not accused of any wrongdoing. He is the measuring stick: if the biggest catalogue on the service was inflated, the dilution was largest there.

The paragraph that is the whole argument

This is the part worth reading slowly, because it is the industry’s best single description of the actual complaint — enforcement that runs downhill but never uphill. From Collins’ amended filing:

“Spotify rigorously polices the low end of its streaming platform, where enforcement costs Spotify nothing and in fact, benefits its bottom line by imposing minimum-stream and unique listener thresholds that strip royalties from emerging and independent artists. Yet, at the same time, Spotify declines to apply that same scrutiny to artificial streaming that inflates the catalogs of its highest-volume, ‘A-list,’ most lucrative artists such as Drake — the very accounts whose streams drive Spotify’s reported monthly active users, engagement metrics, and advertising revenue.”

That is not a wild claim. It describes a system with two enforcement speeds — and it points at the one asymmetry that matters: the bottom of the platform gets audited and demonetized, and the top gets reported as growth. Since April 2024, a track needs 1,000 streams in twelve months plus an undisclosed minimum of unique listeners before it earns recording royalties at all.

The evidence the filing put forward

The specifics were unusually granular for a complaint, which is why the case got taken seriously by the industry press when it landed. Among the allegations:

• Over a 48-month sampling period through 2025, a substantial percentage of Drake’s roughly 37 billion Spotify streams were inauthentic and “appeared to be the work of a sprawling network of bot accounts.”

• In 2024, 250,000 plays of the Drake track “No Face” over a four-day window were routed from Turkey by VPN but mapped to the United Kingdom.

• Some accounts streamed for 23 hours a day, and fewer than 2% of users were allegedly responsible for about 15% of streams.

• The complaint argued Spotify’s free tier made this easy, since a bot can register without a credit card.

Collins asked for compensatory and punitive damages, an order forcing Spotify to tighten sign-up with CAPTCHAs and a valid phone number or card, and a court-supervised independent monitor to police the platform.

First dismissal: no duty

On June 22, 2026, Judge Josephine Staton granted Spotify’s motion to dismiss both claims. Her reasoning was narrow and it is the reason this story is not really about music at all.

Collins had not shown that Spotify owed him a legal duty to protect him from third-party bots. That is the whole case, in one sentence. Not “the allegations are false” — but “even if every one of them is true, Spotify never promised you that.” On the Unfair Competition claim, she wrote that he “failed to plausibly allege that the harm he has suffered outweighs any justification Spotify may have” for its current policies. She also questioned the near-exclusive focus on a single artist, noting it was unclear how much Collins himself had been injured by artificial streaming across the platform.

She dismissed both claims with leave to amend — the standard second chance.

Second dismissal: with prejudice

He amended, and refiled, and lost again. On October 23, 2026, Staton granted Spotify’s request to throw the case out — and this time barred RBX from bringing the same claims again. The ruling runs 16 pages.

The line that matters for anyone watching from the independent tier: “Although Plaintiff may have less power in the music industry as compared to Spotify, that does not mean his relationship with Spotify is characterized” by a legal duty of the kind he alleged. Being the weaker party is not, by itself, a claim.

Spotify’s answer, and the number that hurts

Spotify’s statement when the suit was filed was that the company “in no way benefits from the industry-wide challenge of artificial streaming,” and that it invests in systems that remove fake streams, withhold royalties and charge penalties.

Then it offered the fact that does the most damage to the dilution theory: in the Michael Smith case — the North Carolina man sentenced in October 2026 to 18 months for AI-assisted streaming fraud — only about $60,000 of the roughly $10 million alleged came from Spotify. If the fraud isn’t concentrated on one platform, the “Spotify took my slice” theory shrinks. That is Spin the defense is entitled to, and it is a strong one.

The other cases, because the pattern is the story

Drake, November 2024. Through Frozen Moments LLC, Drake filed a petition accusing Universal Music Group and Spotify of artificially inflating “Not Like Us” with bots. UMG called it “offensive and untrue.” Drake withdrew the petition and sued UMG for defamation in January 2025. A New York judge dismissed that defamation case in October 2025, holding the song was protected opinion. Drake is appealing.

Genevieve Capolongo, November 2025. A Spotify subscriber sued over Discovery Mode, calling it “modern payola” — the feature where artists accept a lower royalty rate for a shot at algorithmic reach. A New York judge sent it to arbitration in April 2026 and dismissed the class claims. Fans can’t sue over it either.

Three separate fronts, three exits that never reach the merits: dismissed for leave, dismissed with prejudice, and pushed into arbitration.

SPLASH’S READ

SPLASH'S READ: This is the most useful case in streaming because it lost on the right ground, and the right ground is a wall. The dilution argument is correct arithmetic. A fake stream comes out of a shared pot, so it is a pay cut for everyone in it. Nobody seriously disputes that. What the court said is that arithmetic isn’t a cause of action — a platform doesn’t owe you a number, it owes you a contract. And the contract you signed to distribute your music doesn’t promise you a clean pool.

That is the whole shape of the music business in one docket. You can be right, provably right, and have no remedy — because the wrong is real and the duty is private. The remedy for a private duty is the agreement, and the agreement runs through a distributor that gets paid before you do. Which is why the practical answer in this business has never been a lawsuit. It’s owning something — the master, the publishing, the audience list, the ticket — that isn’t bought out of a pool somebody else divides.

And the line from the complaint about two enforcement speeds is still standing after both dismissals. The court never said it was wrong. It said it wasn’t illegal. Those are different findings, and only one of them gets published as a headline.

Watch: Top Music Attorney. Sources & claims: Music Business Worldwide (Mandy Dalugdug) — June 23, 2026, “Spotify wins dismissal of lawsuit claiming it allowed ‘billions’ of fraudulent Drake streams,” for the June 22 ruling by Judge Josephine Staton, C.D. Cal., the no-duty finding, the UCL rejection, her skepticism about the single-artist focus, Spotify’s “in no way benefits” statement, and the $60,000-of-$10-million Michael Smith comparison; and October 27, 2026, “Spotify wins permanent dismissal,” for the October 23 dismissal with prejudice, the 16-page ruling, and the quoted passage on power in the music industry. Rolling Stone and Pitchfork (November 3, 2025) for the original filing. Complaint quotations — the “rigorously polices the low end” paragraph, the 37 billion figure, the $600 million estimate, the 250,000 “No Face” plays routed Turkey-to-UK, the 23 hours a day and <2% of users / 15% of streams allegations, and the CAPTCHA/monitor requests — are allegations from RBX’s amended complaint, reported by MBW and Rolling Stone, and are not findings by any court. Drake is not a defendant and is not accused of wrongdoing here. Spotify has denied benefiting from artificial streaming, and its position is set out in the body. The Michael Smith sentence and forfeiture figure ($8,091,843.64, Judge John G. Koeltl, S.D.N.Y., October 6, 2026) were covered separately on this site at /streaming-fraud-8-million. Video sources: Top Music Attorney (November 7, 2025) and Con Empire (October 14, 2026) — both used for context only. Correction to the Top Music Attorney video: it asks “do we believe this?” and was recorded before the answer arrived — the case was dismissed in June 2026 and dismissed with prejudice in October 2026.