THE CLAUSE. 35% of the cap, no competing bid, and no way to say no. The supermax isn't a valuation — it's a ransom with a salary cap attached.
THE CLAUSE. The NBA's supermax — formally the Designated Veteran Player Extension — was created in the 2017 collective bargaining agreement for one purpose: to stop teams from losing homegrown superstars in free agency.
The pitch to the players was simple. A player with seven or eight years of service who makes an All-NBA team, wins MVP or wins Defensive Player of the Year becomes eligible for a starting salary up to 35% of the cap instead of the usual 30%. The team that drafted him can pay more than anyone else — so he stays.
Nine years later, it has produced the largest contracts in the history of team sports and the worst contracts in the league, sometimes in the same season. And the reason is structural, not personal.
THE PRICE IS SET BY LEVERAGE, NOT VALUE. Every other contract in sports is negotiated against an alternative. A team can walk away from a good player, sign a cheaper one, or trade for someone else. The supermax removes all three options.
If a team declines to offer it, the player becomes disgruntled, requests a trade, and the franchise gets pennies on the dollar. If the team offers it, it pays a number the market never tested — because no other team was allowed to bid. The 35% figure isn't what the player is worth. It's what the player can credibly threaten to take elsewhere.
That's why the deals are so large and so unrelated to production. The supermax isn't a valuation. It's a ransom with a salary cap attached.
THE ONES THAT WORKED. The design isn't stupid — it has produced exactly what it promised when the player is durable and the team is good.
Stephen Curry: five years, $201 million in 2017. He won two more championships on that deal. Nikola Jokić: five years, $264 million in 2022. He won a title and three MVPs. Giannis Antetokounmpo: five years, $228 million in 2020, followed by a championship in 2021.
In each case the team paid the maximum and got a top-five player in his prime for the entire term. That's the deal working exactly as designed.
THE ONES THAT DIDN'T. The same clause, applied to a player whose body or game doesn't hold, produces the least tradeable contracts in the sport.
John Wall: four years, $170 million in 2017 — then a ruptured Achilles, a trade, and a buyout. Russell Westbrook: five years, $205 million in 2017 — traded within two seasons as the team rebuilt around a different player. Both were defensible at signing. Both became the reason their teams couldn't rebuild.
That's the asymmetry nobody prices at signing: a 35% contract that works is a championship foundation; a 35% contract that fails is a five-year moratorium on flexibility.
THE NUMBERS NOW. The ceiling keeps moving because the cap keeps moving.
Jaylen Brown signed a five-year, $304 million supermax in 2023 — the first $300 million contract in NBA history. A year later, Jayson Tatum signed five years, $315 million — the largest contract ever signed in the league.
Boston is paying two players roughly $60 million a season each in the same window. That works when they win a championship, which they did in 2024. It becomes a crisis the moment one of them gets hurt — and there is no version of the CBA that lets the Celtics escape it.
THE SECOND APRON MAKES IT WORSE. The 2023 CBA added punitive luxury-tax tiers — the first and second aprons — that strip teams of exceptions, freeze first-round picks and block trades for teams above the line. A supermax that fails doesn't just cost money now; it locks a franchise out of the mechanisms it would use to fix the mistake.
So the modern supermax has two failure modes stacked on top of each other: the contract is unmoveable, and the roster around it is un-improvable.
WHY TEAMS KEEP SIGNING THEM. Because the alternative is worse. Let a homegrown star walk and you don't get cap space — you get a fan revolt, a trade demand, and a rebuild with no assets. The supermax is expensive; losing the player is existential.
Every general manager knows the math. The contract is a bad deal in the abstract and the only deal available in practice. That's not a market — it's a hostage exchange with a press conference.
SPLASH'S READ: The supermax is the cleanest example in sports of a price that has nothing to do with value. It exists to solve a league problem — star retention — and the cost of solving it is paid by whichever team happens to employ a star whose knee gives out.
So when someone calculates the "most efficient supermax dollar," the answer is always going to be the same kind of player: a durable MVP-level star who wins a title inside the window. Curry, Jokić, Giannis, Tatum. Everyone else is a bet that didn't land, priced at a number nobody negotiated.
The most efficient dollar in the NBA isn't a contract. It's a healthy knee.