⌕

THE $650,000 GOALIE

NOV 18, 2026 · SPLASH · NHL · BLUES, BINNINGTON, MONEY
The $650,000 goalie

LAST IN THE LEAGUE IN JANUARY. STANLEY CUP IN JUNE. St. Louis won it on a $650,000 rookie goaltender and a centre whose signing bonus another team had already paid.

THE TEAM THAT WON THE 2019 STANLEY CUP WAS DEAD LAST IN THE LEAGUE IN JANUARY. The goalie who carried them made $650,000 — while the goalie he beat in Game 7 made seven million.

LAST PLACE

St. Louis fired head coach Mike Yeo on 19 November 2018 and made assistant Craig Berube interim coach. It didn't fix anything. By early January the Blues were last overall in the NHL — 31st of 31 — and their 52-year wait for a Cup looked like it would run another year.

They were, in the most expensive sense, a mediocre team: a real payroll, a real roster, a goaltending problem. Jake Allen was the starter and he was losing his net.

The fix wasn't a trade or a system change. It was a call-up.

$650,000

Jordan Binnington was 25, on a one-year deal worth $650,000, and had spent years in the AHL waiting behind other people. He got the net in January and did what almost never happens in professional sports: he was immediately, demonstrably better than everyone expected.

His regular season: 24–5–1, a 1.89 goals-against average, a .927 save percentage and five shutouts across 32 appearances — the best season by a rookie goaltender in Blues history. Then he started all 26 playoff games.

At the other end of the Final was Tuukka Rask, on an eight-year, $56 million contract carrying a $7 million cap hit and a $7 million salary. Same position, same series, ten times the money.

Binnington won Game 7, 4–1, with 32 saves.

WHY THEY COULDN'T JUST BUY A GOALIE

Here's the cap math that made the whole thing possible, and it's the part fans skip.

St. Louis had committed to Jake Allen on a four-year, $17.4 million extension — an average of $4.35 million against the cap — and had traded away the goalie he replaced to hand him the net. In a hard cap, that's not a contract, it's a commitment. You can't sign a $7 million replacement without moving money out, and you can't move a struggling goalie's contract mid-season without paying somebody to take it.

So the only available upgrade was the one already in the organization, on a two-way deal, making near the league minimum. Binnington wasn't a clever signing. He was the only door left open.

That's how most great underdog runs actually start: not with a smart executive out-thinking the market, but with a team that has spent itself into a corner and has no choice but to try the cheap option.

THE OTHER CHEAP MOVE

The Blues' other bargain was less lucky and more interesting. On the opening day of free agency in July 2018 they acquired Ryan O'Reilly from Buffalo for three forwards and two draft picks.

There was a detail in that trade that tells you how NHL economics actually work. O'Reilly was owed a $7.5 million signing bonus on 1 July. Buffalo paid it — and then traded him. St. Louis got a $7.5 million player and spent none of that money acquiring him.

O'Reilly went on to win the Conn Smythe as playoff MVP. So the Blues' two most important players in that run were a $650,000 goalie nobody wanted and a centre whose bonus somebody else had already paid.

WHAT THE RUN WAS WORTH

Binnington earned $650,000 for the season that made him a Stanley Cup champion. Weeks later he signed a two-year deal worth $8.8 million. Eventually he signed for six years and $36 million.

That is the entire economics of the thing in one arc. He was paid like a backup while performing like a star, and the difference between those two numbers is what made the roster work. A team can't afford three stars and a $7 million goalie in a hard cap — so the only way to win cheap is to have somebody outperform their contract, badly and quickly, before anyone can reprice them.

Every underdog champion in a cap league is built the same way: one or two players on contracts that are wrong in the team's favour, for exactly as long as it takes the market to correct.

SPLASH’S READ

People call it a miracle because it looks like one from the outside. From the inside it's an accounting story: a last-place team with a bad goaltending contract found a better goalie making one-ninth of the money, and a good team with a $7 million goalie couldn't solve him four times in seven games.

The part that makes it a real story is the timing. Binnington's window of being underpaid was exactly one season — the one the Blues needed. Twelve months later he was priced correctly and the arbitrage was gone.

And the honest flip side: the same system that made St. Louis a champion is the reason good players get squeezed. The Cup was won on the back of someone being underpaid. That's not a fairy tale, it's a market inefficiency with a parade attached.

WHAT WE COULDN’T CONFIRM

The exact date the Blues hit last overall is reported as early January 2019 (commonly 3 January); the standings position is well documented, the precise game date varies by source.

The O’Reilly bonus. That Buffalo paid the $7.5 million bonus due on 1 July 2018 before completing the trade is widely reported; the precise timing relative to the paperwork is described differently in different accounts, so we state what was paid, not the hour it cleared.

Binnington’s stats — 24–5–1, 1.89, .927, five shutouts, 32 appearances, 26 playoff starts — are from the NHL’s official season summary.

Rask’s $7 million is his 2018–19 salary and cap hit under an eight-year, $56 million contract.

The video that prompted this is a fan-produced retelling; every figure here was checked against the league record, the contract databases and contemporaneous reporting.

MORE ON THE BOARD ▸
NHL · The Money · All Stories
Sources & claims: Mike Yeo's dismissal and Craig Berube's appointment as interim coach on 19 November 2018 are from the NHL's and contemporaneous reporting; the Blues sitting last overall in the league in early January 2019, and the first Stanley Cup in the franchise's 52-year history, are from the league's season record and NHL.com; Jordan Binnington's one-year, $650,000 contract for 2018–19 is from PuckPedia's contract record, and his 24–5–1 record, 1.89 GAA, .927 save percentage, five shutouts, 32 appearances and 26 playoff starts are from the NHL's official season summary; his subsequent two-year, $8.8 million deal is from ESPN's reporting and the six-year, $36 million contract is from contract databases; Tuukka Rask's $7 million 2018–19 salary and cap hit under an eight-year, $56 million contract are from the Bruins' cap record; the July 2016 Jake Allen extension (four years, $17.4m, $4.35m AAV) is from the league's announcement; the July 2018 O'Reilly trade with Buffalo for three forwards and two draft picks, and the $7.5 million bonus, are from NHL.com and Buffalo Hockey Beat's reporting; the Game 7 result of 12 June 2019 and Binnington's 32 saves are from the NHL's game record.