⌕

THE ROOT BEER WARS

NOV 18, 2026 · SPLASH · EXPLAINERS · HIRES, A&W, BARQ’S, MUG
The root beer wars — Hires, A&W, Mug and Barq's

FOUR BRANDS, THREE GIANTS, TEN YEARS. Root beer was the first soft drink sold coast to coast. Then Pepsi, Coke and Cadbury bought every name in the category inside a decade — and the one brand nobody bought is the one you can't find.

ROOT BEER WAS AMERICA'S FIRST NATIONAL SOFT DRINK, AND THEN IT GOT BOUGHT. Hires was on shelves across the country before Coke or Pepsi were local names in Georgia and North Carolina. A century later, in a ten-year window, all four surviving brands were absorbed by the three soda giants — and the shelf closed behind them.

THE ORIGINAL

Charles Elmer Hires started working in a pharmacy at twelve, owned his own in Philadelphia by eighteen, and created root beer at twenty-four. The story says a pie recipe inspired it.

He got lucky with the calendar. The following year was the country's centennial, and Philadelphia hosted the Centennial Exposition of 1876 — a six-month fair attended by an estimated ten million people. Hires root beer sold there, and sold hard.

He had planned to call it an herbal tea. He was advised that calling it a beer would reach more people, so he did — which is how a temperance drink ended up with alcohol in the name.

Then he did the thing nobody else had done: shipped it as a concentrate to pharmacies nationwide so any soda fountain could sell it. For a stretch in the late 1800s, Hires was the only nationally distributed soft drink in America, while Coke, Pepsi and Dr Pepper were still local names in three different states.

THE INGREDIENT PROBLEM

Root beer was built on sassafras. Around 1960, the FDA moved against safrole — the compound in sassafras oil — after high doses caused liver cancer in lab rats. Every brand had to reformulate.

Hires did, and kept selling. It stayed the best-selling root beer into the 1970s — roughly a century at the top — before someone finally passed it.

THE ONE THAT PASSED IT

In June 1919, Roy W. Allen opened a root beer stand in Lodi, California, using a formula he'd bought from a pharmacist. Frank Wright came in as a partner, and the initials — Allen and Wright — became the name.

Then the timing broke their way. Prohibition ran from 1920 to 1933. Selling something called root beer while actual beer was illegal was free advertising.

In 1925 they started franchising the stands, which was close to unheard of. Two years later a young couple opened a nine-seat A&W franchise in Washington, D.C. as their first business — J. Willard and Alice Marriott, who went on to build the hotel chain. A&W is now widely described as the first franchised restaurant chain in the country.

The bottling came much later, in the 1970s, after the company had passed through United Brands — the Chiquita company. Once the bottles hit grocery shelves with a major company behind them, it took about five years to pass Hires, and A&W has led the category ever since.

Then it came apart. The Canadian restaurants, the American restaurants and the beverage division were sold to three different owners. The Canadian chain, with over a thousand locations, now has roughly double the U.S. count on a much smaller population. The bottles went to Cadbury Schweppes in 1993.

THE COLLISION

Cadbury Schweppes had already bought Crush International, which owned Hires. So the two most famous root beers in history — the original and the leader — ended up inside the same company.

There was only ever going to be one winner in that arrangement. A&W was bigger, newer and growing; Hires was the heritage brand. Hires got neglected, and then discontinued. Cadbury bought Dr Pepper in 1995, which is why both names now sit under Keurig Dr Pepper — and why one of them is a memory.

THE TWO THAT CAME LATE

Mug arrived in the San Francisco area in 1940, originally as Belfast Root Beer, then Belfast Old Fashioned Mug, then just Mug. Pepsi had tried root beer before under other labels and failed. Mug, bought in 1986, was its first real investment in the category — complete with a bulldog mascot named Dog.

Coca-Cola, meanwhile, was losing. Its entry was Ramblin', launched in 1979 with a jingle people still remember and sales nobody does.

So Coke bought Barq's in 1995 — its first acquisition of a U.S. carbonated beverage brand, and its first U.S. beverage purchase of any kind since Minute Maid thirty-five years earlier.

THE BARQ'S THING

This is the part that belongs to my city, so let me get it right, because most retellings don't.

Barq Brothers Bottling Co. was founded in New Orleans in 1890 by Edward and Gaston Barq, in the French Quarter. Their first hit wasn't root beer — it was Orangine, an orange soda that won a gold medal at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago.

The root beer came later and it came from Biloxi, Mississippi, after the brothers moved to the Gulf Coast around 1897. So the name is New Orleans and the drink is Mississippi. Both are true, and the distinction is usually flattened into one line.

Barq's didn't even call itself root beer for decades. Hires was trying to trademark the term, so Barq's steered around it — the slogan was simply Drink Barq's. It's good. And it had a real legal problem the others didn't: Barq's is caffeinated, which ran into laws against putting caffeine in that kind of soda.

The caffeine is why it survived. It tasted different, and in the 1990s it got a slogan to match: Barq's has bite.

THE PATTERN

Four brands, three giants, one window:

1986 — Pepsi buys Mug.
1993 — Cadbury Schweppes buys A&W.
1995 — Coca-Cola buys Barq's.
1995 — Cadbury buys Dr Pepper, absorbing Hires with it.

Ten years. That's the entire consolidation of a category that had been independent for a hundred.

And the one that didn't get bought is the proof of what happens next. Dad's — the yellow-label brand from a Chicago basement in the 1930s — was selling 12 million cases a year and held the second-largest share when Monarch Beverage bought it in 1986. It never became part of a giant, so it never got the distribution. It's still made. It's just hard to find.

Root beer today is about 3 percent of the U.S. soft drink market. Not because people stopped liking it — because the shelf, the cooler and the bottler network all belong to three companies, and they already have a root beer.

SPLASH’S READ

Root beer is the clearest case I know of a category that invented brand loyalty and then got enclosed.

Think about what Hires actually built: a drink nobody could make at home, sold as a concentrate through every pharmacy in the country, before refrigeration, before national distribution was a thing anybody had done. For a while, root beer was the most modern product in America.

Then the industry figured out that the way to win a category isn't to make a better root beer. It's to own the brands and the trucks. And once three companies own every significant name in a 3-percent category, the category stops producing new names. Not by conspiracy — by arithmetic.

Which is why the interesting question isn't “which root beer is best.” It's how many things in your grocery store arrived at that shelf the same way — a good local product, bought by somebody bigger, and then quietly kept alive at the size that doesn't threaten anything.

Hires didn't lose because it tasted worse. It lost because it got bought by the company that also owned the winner.

WHAT WE COULDN’T CONFIRM

Whether Hires was created in 1875 or 1876. The recipe is dated 1875 in most accounts and the brand was introduced to the public at the 1876 Centennial. Both years show up in retellings; the Exposition is the documented debut.

The exact year of the A&W bottling push and the United Brands purchase. The sequence is documented — restaurants first, bottling decades later — but the years move depending on the source, so we've described the order rather than pinning a date we couldn't confirm twice.

The 3 percent figure. It's the commonly cited share for root beer within U.S. soft drinks; different trackers slice the category differently.

Whether Barq's root beer was 1898 or 1899. The company's New Orleans founding in 1890 is solid; the Biloxi root beer is usually dated 1898, and some sources round it.

MORE ON THE BOARD ▸
Explainers · The Money · All Stories
Watch: Company Man. Sources & claims: Hires: Charles Elmer Hires, the 1875 recipe, the 1876 Centennial Exposition debut and the national concentrate business are from the brand's own history and the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia; the safrole/FDA action is from the public record on sassafras and is usually dated around 1960. A&W: Roy W. Allen's June 20, 1919 Lodi stand, the 1925 franchising, the Marriott franchise and the Prohibition timing are from A&W's own company history and Wikipedia's A&W Root Beer entry; the Cadbury Schweppes acquisition and the Dr Pepper deal are from contemporaneous business reporting. Mug: the 1940 Belfast origin and the 1986 Pepsi purchase are from PepsiCo brand history. Barq's: the 1890 New Orleans founding of Barq Brothers Bottling Co., Orangine's 1893 gold medal and the Biloxi origin of the root beer are from Rien Fertel's entry for 64 Parishes, the Louisiana encyclopedia, and the 1995 Coca-Cola acquisition is from the brand's own about page. Dad's: the Chicago origin and the 12-million-case figure at the 1986 Monarch acquisition are from the brand's history and Wikipedia. The consolidation window and the ~3 percent category share are from period reporting; share figures vary by tracker.