GEORGIA INDICTED 28 PEOPLE IN MAY 2022 AND SPENT TWO AND A HALF YEARS TRYING THEM. It became the longest trial in the state's history. When it ended on 3 December 2024, the last two defendants walked out not guilty, Young Thug had been sentenced to time served, and the question at the centre of it — whether a record label was a gang — was never answered by a jury.
WHAT THE STATE ALLEGED
The indictment said YSL stood for Young Slime Life, a criminal street gang operating out of Atlanta, and that Jeffery Williams — Young Thug — was one of its founders.
The charge was RICO: a pattern of racketeering activity, with predicate acts stretching back years, tried as a conspiracy rather than one crime at a time.
That structure is the whole point of a RICO case. It lets the state put twenty people in one courtroom, use one defendant's act against another, and present the organisation itself as the thing on trial.
HOW IT GOT HERE
The indictment reaches back a decade, and the earliest entries look nothing like a gang case.
2012: Young Thug starts YSL in Atlanta, much of it drawn from the Jonesboro apartments where he grew up. The state's theory is that this was a gang with ties to established Blood sets; the defence's theory is that it was a crew that became a label.
2013: he catches a gun charge and theft by receiving stolen property. At the time it is a minor case. In the RICO paperwork it becomes an overt act — the legal building block that lets an old, small offence be used as a piece of a decade-long conspiracy.
2015: Donovan “Big Nut” Thomas Jr. is shot and killed in Atlanta. This is the heart of the case. Five men were charged with the murder — not Thug — but prosecutors alleged he rented the silver Infiniti used in the shooting, which is why the car matters more than the trigger in the indictment.
The alleged motive was Thomas's association with a rival camp. There is no evidence he cooperated with police; that rumour circulated, and it is a rumour.
WHAT THE DEFENCE SAID
That YSL was a record label — Young Stoner Life Records — and that a label, its artists, its producers and its hangers-on are not a gang because the state decided to call them one.
And that the evidence being used to prove the gang existed was, in large part, the music: videos, lyrics, Instagram posts.
Which is the argument this case made unavoidable and that every other rap trial since has had to answer: a lyric can be evidence of a crime, but is it evidence of a conspiracy?
HOW LONG IT TOOK
Jury selection began in January 2023 and took ten months.
Testimony started on 27 November 2023. More than 200 witnesses were called. The trial was interrupted by the removal of the presiding judge, Ural Glanville, who was recused after a meeting with prosecutors and a witness that defence lawyers said tainted the case; Paige Reese Whitaker took over.
It finished on 3 December 2024 — Georgia's longest trial in history.
HOW IT ENDED
Not with a verdict on the theory. With a series of exits.
Gunna made an Alford plea in December 2022 and was sentenced to time served — a plea that kept him out of the trial and, for a large part of hip-hop, settled nothing about what he had said or not said.
On 31 October 2024, Young Thug pleaded guilty to gang, drug and firearms charges. Judge Whitaker imposed 40 years: the first 5 years in prison were commuted to time served, followed by 15 years of probation — with the remaining 20 years backloaded to hang over him if he violates the terms. Prosecutors had asked for 45 years, 25 of them in prison.
He was released that night.
On 3 December 2024, the last two defendants — Deamonte Kendrick and Shannon Stillwell — were found not guilty.
THE TERMS HE ACTUALLY HAS TO LIVE WITH
The 40-year sentence is not a number he serves. It is a structure:
15 years of probation, with the final 20 years backloaded — held over him, to be imposed if he violates. He has to leave metro Atlanta within 48 hours of release and stay out for the first 10 years, with narrow exceptions: weddings, funerals, graduations, serious illness.
He must complete 100 hours of community service over the decade, give four live anti-gang, anti-gun-violence presentations a year to young people, and he cannot own a firearm.
Which is a sentence designed to do something prison would not: it keeps the most famous defendant in the case out of the city that made him, and makes his freedom conditional on him publicly arguing against the life the state says he led.
WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED, IN ONE PARAGRAPH
Twenty-eight people were indicted. After two and a half years, the longest trial in the state's history produced: a time-served plea from the most famous defendant, a time-served plea from Gunna, a handful of other pleas, and acquittals for the last two men standing.
Nobody was convicted by a jury of being part of the gang the state spent all that time describing. The convictions in the case came from people pleading — and the last word from a jury was not guilty.
SPLASH'S READ
The state's theory was that the label was a gang. It never got a jury to say so.
What it got instead was a decade of people's lives and a legal bill that Georgia taxpayers are still paying — and a precedent that will be argued about in every rap case the state brings next.
Thug walked out because he took the deal that ended it. That is not a victory and it is not a defeat. It is a 40-year sentence with the prison part already served, which is what a case looks like when everybody needs it to stop.
Sources & claims: Sources. The indictment: returned in May 2022 against 28 defendants, alleging YSL — Young Slime Life — was a criminal street gang and charging Young Thug and others under Georgia's RICO statute. Duration: jury selection began January 2023 and took ten months; testimony began 27 November 2023; more than 200 witnesses; the trial ended 3 December 2024 and was reported as the longest trial in Georgia history (
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution; AP; Courthouse News). Judicial change: Judge Ural Glanville was recused mid-trial and replaced by Judge Paige Reese Whitaker. The plea and sentence: on 31 October 2024 Young Thug pleaded guilty to gang, drug and firearms charges; sentenced to 40 years with the first five commuted to time served, followed by 15 years of probation, with a backloaded term if probation is violated; prosecutors had sought 45 years with 25 in prison (AP; NPR;
The New York Times). Gunna: Alford plea, December 2022, time served. Verdicts: the final two defendants were found not guilty on 3 December 2024 (Courthouse News; AP). Special conditions of probation: he was ordered to leave metro Atlanta within 48 hours of release and stay away for the first 10 years except for weddings, funerals, graduations or serious illness; 100 hours of community service over 10 years; four live anti-gang and anti-gun-violence presentations a year; no firearm (
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, 4 November 2024; AP, 1 November 2024). The 2015 killing: Donovan Thomas Jr.; five men were charged with the murder, not Young Thug, and the indictment alleged he rented the vehicle used (indictment; AP, May 2022). Video source:
Trap Lore Ross, “Getting Away With Murder: Young Thug's Insane Trial” (
p9k0088btyM);
Hip-Hop Daily, “YSL Rico: The Craziest Case in Rap History Breakdown” (
VmwJ77voN_4). Related:
Tay-K and
the 6ix9ine case.