THE CORRECTION. No boardroom chant. No refused job. The NCAA said yes two months early. And the coach the film sends home kept coaching another year.
THE DATE. November 14, 2026 is the 56th anniversary of the crash of Southern Airways Flight 932. Marshall holds its Memorial Fountain Ceremony at 10 a.m. on the Memorial Student Center Plaza, then hosts Appalachian State that night.
Every year the fountain is turned off and 75 flowers are laid on it — one for each person who died. In spring it runs again.
And every year, for most of four decades, one man stood off to the side beside a tree, cutting a single notch into it with a knife he carried.
THE CRASH. On November 14, 1970, Marshall's football team flew home from a game at East Carolina — a 17-14 loss in Greenville. The chartered DC-9 left Kinston at 6:38 p.m. and began its approach to Tri-State Airport outside Huntington at about 7:36.
There was no glide slope at the airport to guide it down. In rain and fog, at night, the plane came in too low and hit trees on a hill about a mile short of the runway. Investigators never established why it descended.
75 people died: 37 players, 8 coaches and staff, 25 boosters and fans, and 5 crew. Among them the head coach, Rick Tolley, who was 29; the athletic director; the trainer; and the radio announcer, Gene Morehouse, who left a wife and six children.
Six players could not be identified. They were buried together in Huntington.
WHO WASN'T ABOARD — AND WHY. The roll of near-misses is the part that makes this story unbearable:
Red Dawson, the 27-year-old defensive coordinator, drove down in a university station wagon because he had a recruiting visit planned on the way home. A graduate assistant, Gail Parker, rode with him.
The kicking coach, Dee Brackett, had also driven down — but flew home to get back faster, and Parker took his seat in the car.
Art Harris Sr. had come to watch his son play halfback. He decided to fly home with the team. Both died.
Nate Ruffin, the co-captain, was hurt and didn't travel. A lineman was in Texas for his father's funeral. Two assistants were scouting at Penn State.
The cheerleaders didn't go — their rule was all go or none go, and there wasn't room for all of them.
And Tolley's wife, Mary Jane, stayed home because their dog was sick.
WHAT THE MOVIE GOT WRONG. We Are Marshall (2006) is a good film and a generous one. It is also, on five specific points, not what happened.
1. The chant. The film's emotional center is Nate Ruffin rallying students beneath the board of governors' window, chanting "We are Marshall" until the program is saved. That scene didn't happen. The chant came years later — Jack Lengyel said plainly that "the chant was never a part of our game."
What actually happened was quieter and faster: within days, acting president Donald Dedmon told the surviving players the program would not be shut down.
2. The coach who refused the job. In the film, Dawson is offered the acting head coaching position and turns it down. The real Dawson wanted it and took it. For four months he ran Marshall's football program, signed a class of 21 recruits, and planned a staff — and Dedmon backed him for the permanent job.
Then Marshall hired Dick Bestwick, a Georgia Tech assistant. A member of the athletic committee told Dawson he had never been a serious candidate: too young, no head coaching experience, no master's degree. Bestwick left within days. Dawson was then told he was out of the running entirely — and said he wouldn't take it now even if offered.
The film invented a man who nobly declined. The real man was passed over.
3. The NCAA waiver. The movie has Marshall petition the NCAA for permission to play freshmen after Lengyel arrives. The NCAA had already said yes two months before he was hired — and had done the same for Wichita State, whose plane crashed six weeks before Marshall's.
4. The ending of Dawson's career. The film's closing card says he left the team at the end of that year and never returned to football. He coached one more season and left after 1972. He never coached again. Years later he wrote that he "somehow lost about a year of my life, including the 1972 football season."
5. The game ball. In the film, Lengyel hands it to the university president. In the real locker room, the team gave it to Red Dawson.
THE SEASON THAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED. Jack Lengyel was hired in March 1971 — 35 years old, from the College of Wooster in Ohio, coming off a 7-2 season. He had nine varsity players who hadn't traveled that night, plus freshmen, plus walk-ons.
On September 18, 1971, ten months after the crash, Marshall played football again at Morehead State — the team it had beaten in its opener a year earlier. About 4,000 Marshall fans made the trip. Marshall lost 29-6.
Then the kicker quit. Lengyel advertised for a replacement and got Blake Smith, a soccer player from New York who had never played a game of football. He kicked a football for the first time four days before the next game.
September 25, 1971 — the first home game since the crash, against Xavier. More than 13,000 people at Fairfield Stadium, including the governor and Rick Tolley's parents. Smith kicked a 31-yard field goal as the first quarter ended. It was the only kick Marshall made all season.
Down 13-9 with a minute eighteen left and no timeouts, Reggie Oliver — the last of the Druid High players from Tuscaloosa — completed a fourth-and-10, then another, then found Terry Gardner on a screen. Marshall won 15-13.
In the locker room someone told Blake Smith he didn't have to kick the extra point: "You don't have to kick it. We win. 75 people had something to do with that."
The next week they went to Miami of Ohio and lost 66-6 — Marshall's offense gained two yards all day. They finished 2-8.
HOW LONG IT ACTUALLY TOOK. The film ends on the Xavier win and the line "from the ashes we rose." It took thirteen years. Marshall's next winning season was 1984. In the 1990s it won two national championships in what was then Division I-AA.
Nate Ruffin, captain of the 1971 team, died in 2001 and is buried at Spring Hill Cemetery beside his teammates.
THE MAN BY THE TREE. In 1990, Marshall's new head coach, Jim Donnan, was told Dawson's name by Keith Morehouse — Gene Morehouse's son, who was nine when his father died on that plane, grew up to call Marshall games on the radio in his father's old job, and married Debbie Hagley, whose parents were on the plane too. Keith is in the film as himself.
Donnan started inviting Dawson to practice. Dawson made excuses for a while, then ran out of them.
And every November, he stood beside that tree. "Sometimes behind it," he said, "cutting a single notch in it every year, with a knife I carried." In 2005, Marshall's president asked him to come and join the crowd. The next year, he gave the keynote.
He also worked as a consultant on We Are Marshall — and appears in it, without a line, as the Morehead State coach, in the film that says he never came back to football.
SPLASH'S READ: The movie needed a hero who refused the job, because a man who refuses is easier to admire than a man who wanted it and was told he wasn't qualified.
The truth is harder and better: Red Dawson tried to rebuild Marshall, got passed over, coached one more year, and then spent thirty-five Novembers standing alone beside a tree being quietly counted.
Seventy-five people died on that hillside. Marshall still lays a flower for every one of them. And the man who cut the notches never asked anybody to notice.