THE ANSWER IS NOT A RUMOUR. IT IS A DATE AND A SENTENCE. On 31 October 2024, the day Young Thug pleaded out of the YSL case, his own lawyer asked the judge for permission to keep working with Gunna — and got it. Less than a year later he said he could never look at him the same way again: “I still want you to eat, just not at my table.”
WHAT GUNNA ACTUALLY DID
In December 2022, Gunna — Sergio Kitchens — took an Alford plea and was released on time served.
An Alford plea is a guilty plea entered while maintaining innocence: the defendant accepts the conviction and the sentence but does not admit the facts. What people miss is that the court still requires a factual basis on the record — the state puts its case to him, and he has to agree that the state could prove it.
In his colloquy, that sounded like this:
“I became affiliated with YSL around 2016. Is that true as it pertains to you, Mr. Kitchens?” — “Yes, ma'am.”
“YSL is a music label and a gang, and you have personal knowledge that members or associates of YSL have committed crimes in furtherance of the gang?” — “Yes, ma'am.”
He did not testify against anyone. He did not name a co-defendant. What he did was agree, in open court, that YSL was both a label and a gang.
WHY THAT SPECIFIC LINE CUT SO DEEP
Because that was the entire defence.
Thug's case, for two and a half years, was that YSL was a record label — Young Stoner Life — and that the state had criminalised a music business. Twenty-eight defendants, a decade of acts, and the argument underneath all of it was the difference between a label and a gang.
The man who helped build that label stood in the same courthouse and agreed with the prosecution's central proposition. He walked out that day. Thug stayed in for another twenty-three months.
AND THEN THUG ASKED FOR HIM
Which is the part that makes this story more complicated than a beef.
When Thug finally pleaded out on 31 October 2024, his probation barred contact with YSL associates. His lawyer, Brian Steel, asked the judge for an exemption — not just for Thug's brother, but for Gunna — on the grounds that the two men were “contractually obligated” and “frequently perform music” together. The judge granted it.
So the man who had every reason to be furious made sure, on his way out of the door, that the paperwork did not stop them from working together.
HIS FATHER SAID IT PLAINER
15 September 2023 — a year before any of that, while Thug was still locked up — his father, Jeffrey Williams Sr., was asked about the snitching accusations on the Infamous Sylvia show.
“I love Gunna… Let me try to help the attorney clarify that a little simpler. Gunna hasn't done anything whatsoever that can hurt us on this case. Period.”
He also said he had told Gunna to keep releasing music and keep the label earning while everyone else was inside.
That is why Thug's father “took for Gunna.” He was not guessing. He was in the room where the case was being fought, and he was saying the cooperation was not the thing that hurt them.
WHAT THUG SAYS NOW
Two podcast appearances in September 2025 set out his position.
On the Big Bank show (8 September) he said the betrayal was real to him, and that he believes Gunna cooperated.
On It's Up There (29 September) he was softer and more final:
“We can go get a trillion dollars together. I'm still not gonna be able to look at you the way I looked at you before we went to jail… I love you to death. I know you love me. We love each other to death, and then we just going our own ways.”
And the line that got the headline: “I still want you to eat, just not at my table.”
He also put a jab at Gunna on his album UY SCUTI, so the position is not just interviews.
WHAT GUNNA SAYS
In his first interview after release, with XXL in April 2024, Gunna addressed the accusations directly and described his relationship with Thug as “love always,” while denying he had given anything that harmed him.
His problem was never the plea in the abstract. It was the courtroom video of him answering the judge, which circulated with the “rat” caption attached, and which no explanation was ever going to outrun.
AND THE CITY PICKED SIDES
The split was not only between the two of them. Most of Atlanta went quiet on Gunna after the plea — not because anybody read the transcript, but because the word was out and being seen with him cost something.
Offset was the exception, and he said why on Popcast: that he rides with who rides with him, and that if you only stand next to people while they are winning you cannot expect them to stand next to you when you are not.
That is the real currency in this story. The plea cost Gunna a court case he was never going to win; the label cost him the city. And the people who stayed did it on a personal code, not on a reading of the collateral-hearing record.
WHAT THE RECORD ACTUALLY SAYS
No court has found that Gunna snitched. He never testified. The state's case against Thug did not rest on him.
What he did is on the record and is not in dispute: he took a plea that let him out in December 2022, and he agreed to a factual basis that described YSL as a gang.
Whether that is betrayal is not a legal question. It is a question about what you owe people when the alternative is years of your life, and the two men answer it differently.
SPLASH'S READ
The city has picked sides and mostly picked Thug, and the reason is not really about facts. It is about the code: you do not say the word “gang” in a room where your people are on trial.
But look at the sequence. His father said Gunna did not hurt the case. His own lawyer asked the judge so they could keep working together. Then he came home, sat with it for a year, and decided he could not.
That is not a man repeating a rumour. That is a man who tried to be alright with it and found out he wasn't. Which is a very human thing, and it is also the reason Gunna cannot win the argument no matter what the transcript says.
Sources & claims: Sources. Gunna's plea: Alford plea, December 2022, sentenced to time served; the colloquy passages quoted here — that he became affiliated with YSL around 2016 and agreed YSL was “a music label and a gang” — are from the plea and collateral-hearing transcript as transcribed in the video sources below. Thug's plea and probation: 31 October 2024, 40 years with the first five commuted to time served and 15 years' probation; his attorney Brian Steel requested an exemption allowing contact with Gunna on the grounds that the two were contractually obligated and frequently performed together, which the court granted (
HipHopDX,
Vibe, UPROXX, 31 October–1 November 2024). Thug's father:
Infamous Sylvia interview, 15 September 2023, reported by XXL, Complex and Blavity — “I love Gunna… Gunna hasn't done anything whatsoever that can hurt us on this case. Period.” Gunna's response: XXL cover interview, April 2024. Thug's statements:
Big Bank podcast, 8 September 2025;
It's Up There Podcast, 29 September 2025, as reported by
Billboard and REVOLT — “I still want you to eat, just not at my table.” Album:
UY SCUTI (2025). Video sources:
Louaista, “Why Young Thug Abandoned Gunna” (
9jz9c5CvR-0);
Ceddy Nash, “Offset Chose Gunna Over Thug” (
ERLt6hfS7Yk);
ALL URBAN CENTRAL, “Offset Explains Why He Stayed Friends With Gunna” (
b2GYheiUVzs). Related:
the YSL trial.