DONALD TRUMP SUED THE NFL IN 1983, AND ON 29 JULY 1986 A MANHATTAN JURY AGREED WITH HIM.
It found the NFL liable for antitrust violations. Then it awarded the USFL one dollar — trebled to three dollars under antitrust law.
They asked for $1.69 billion. They got the price of a coffee.
And the league that sued never played another season.
WHY DID TRUMP SUE THE NFL?
Because the NFL had locked up television, and he was the owner who wanted in.
Trump owned the New Jersey Generals of the United States Football League — the spring league that launched in 1983 and, for a minute, looked like a real competitor.
The suit alleged the NFL had monopolized professional football and the broadcast market — that the older league used its network deals to choke the new one before it could grow. The USFL asked for $1.69 billion in damages.
WHAT THE JURY ACTUALLY FOUND
The jury sided with the USFL on liability — the NFL was found to have violated antitrust law.
And then it gutted them on damages. One dollar. Under the antitrust statute, damages are trebled — so three dollars, and reporters at the time wrote it both ways.
Why a dollar: the jury accepted the monopoly argument but didn’t accept that the NFL caused the USFL’s losses. The finding, in effect, was that the new league had damaged itself — through its own decisions about how and when to play.
A verdict that says “you’re right” and awards a dollar is a verdict that says “and it wasn’t them.”
THE DECISION THAT LOST THE CASE
The USFL decided to move from spring to fall — head-to-head against the NFL. Trump was the loudest voice for it.
It was the strategy that made the damages case impossible and the business case worse: a brand-new league with no network leverage, no history and thinner rosters, asking fans to choose it over the most popular product on American television, in the same time slots.
The fall season never happened. The USFL won its lawsuit in July 1986 and suspended operations; it never played another game. Trump’s Generals played their last game in the spring of 1985.
THE SECOND TIME HE WANTED IN
2014 — he tried to buy the Buffalo Bills.
Bankers working the sale doubted the NFL would approve him and encouraged him to stay in the running anyway, according to internal emails reported in 2023. The team went to Terry Pegula for $1.4 billion — a record price for an NFL franchise at the time.
So: he sued the league in 1983, and thirty-one years later he tried to buy his way into it. The lawsuit got him three dollars. The bid got him a rejection.
SPLASH'S READ
This is the cleanest example on this site of the number in the headline not being the number that survives.
He wanted $1.69 billion. He got three dollars. And the strange part is he was right on the law — the jury said so. The law just didn’t pay for being right.
The lesson is in the finding, not the verdict: a jury can agree that the field was tilted and still decide you lost because of how you played it. Monopoly is real, and it is not the same thing as a defense for your own decisions.
And the league that won the case is the one that doesn’t exist. Three dollars was never the point — the point was a product people would choose. The USFL never got one.
Sources & claims: Sources. The Washington Post,
The New York Times and the Los Angeles Times, all
30 July 1986, reporting the verdict of
29 July 1986 in United States District Court, Manhattan:
the jury found the NFL liable for antitrust violations and awarded the USFL $1 in damages, trebled to $3; the USFL had sought
$1.69 billion.
Verified: Trump owned the
New Jersey Generals; the USFL moved to a fall schedule and
never played a fall season, suspending operations after the verdict.
Buffalo Bills: the
2014 sale process, bankers’ doubts reported by the Associated Press in
2023, and the sale to
Terry Pegula for $1.4 billion.
Not published here: any claim about whether the NFL fixes games; this page is about a specific antitrust case and its verdict, not about the integrity of the sport.
No video source; the card is a RapSports house card. Related:
Dipset and
Roc Nation.