THE NUMBER. Three All-Stars, all of them once, all in the same season. Twenty-five years later the 2000 draft is still the floor that every other class gets measured against.
THE NUMBER. Three. Out of sixty players drafted in 2000, exactly three ever made an All-Star team: Kenyon Martin, Jamaal Magloire, and Michael Redd. All three made it once. All three made it in 2004. By any measure, that is the thinnest class the modern NBA has ever produced.
To understand how bad it is, look at what a normal draft does. From 1984 — Jordan's year — through 2020, the average class produced 5.9 All-Stars. The 2000 class produced half that. You have to go back to 1952 to find a draft with fewer than three All-Stars, and that one player made four All-Star teams, which means the 2000 class is worse by every available comparison.
THE TOP OF THE BOARD. Kenyon Martin went first overall to New Jersey — a real player, a defensive anchor, a starter on a team that made the Finals twice. But a first overall pick who averages 16.7 points in his best season and never makes an All-NBA team is a disappointment by the standards of the slot.
Stromile Swift went second. Darius Miles third. Marcus Fizer fourth. Mike Miller fifth — and Miller is the class's best outcome by a distance: Rookie of the Year in 2001, Sixth Man of the Year in 2006 with Memphis, a two-time champion in Miami, and the only player in the entire draft who shot better than 40% from three for his career. The fifth pick was the best pick. That's the class in one sentence.
THE DEPTH THAT WASN'T. Bad classes can still be deep — the 1998 draft produced only five All-Stars but 25 players who lasted a decade in the league. The 2003 class produced 27 ten-year players, the most ever. The 2000 class produced players who were gone.
The totals paint it: only 11 players from the entire draft scored more than 5,000 career points. Four cleared 10,000. Nine averaged double figures for a career. Just two — Michael Redd and Jamal Crawford — ever averaged 20 in a season, and Crawford did it once. Kenyon Martin led the class in career rebounds at 6.8 per game, and he's the only player from the draft with 5,000 boards. Crawford led in assists with 4,541, and no one else reached 3,000. Speedy Claxton led the class in assists per game at 4.3.
Defense? No player from the 2000 draft ever made an All-Defensive team. Not one.
WHY IT HAPPENED. The 2000 draft was the tail end of the high-school-and-euro gamble era, and it was also a genuinely weak high school and college crop at the top. Fizer and Miles were physically gifted players who never found positions. Swift had every measurable and no feel. Martin was the safest pick in the draft — and safety was the whole strategy, because there was nothing to swing at.
The three All-Stars tell the story better than the busts do. Magloire made it because the East had no centers and the ballot guaranteed two center slots. Martin made it because New Jersey was winning. Redd made it because he actually earned it — a second-round pick who became a 20-point scorer and the only genuine steal in sixty picks.
THE ONE THAT WORKED. Michael Redd went 43rd to Milwaukee and became the class's only real star — a 26.7-point scorer in 2006-07, an All-NBA selection in 2004, and a gold medalist with the 2008 Redeem Team. He is also the reason the 2000 draft gets defended at all: a second-round pick who out-earned and out-scored everyone taken ahead of him. Sixty players, and the best one was taken with a pick most teams had already stopped thinking about.
THE OTHER BAD ONES. The 2013 class gave the league Anthony Bennett and the 2006 class gave it Adam Morrison, and both get called busts at the top of the draft. But both produced real depth underneath — 2013 has Giannis, Gobert and McCollum; 2006 has LaMarcus Aldridge, Brandon Roy and Kyle Lowry. The 2000 class doesn't have a rescue underneath it. Its best player went 43rd and the rest is a list of names that stopped existing.
SPLASH'S READ: The 2000 draft is the best argument that tanking is a strategy, not a guarantee. A team that lost on purpose in 1999 got Kenyon Martin — a good player, a Finals starter, a career nobody would call a failure and nobody would call a star.
Compare the class to the two around it and the cruelty is obvious. 1996 gave the league Kobe, Iverson, Nash, Ray Allen — 10 All-Stars and a record 67 combined All-Star selections. 2003 gave it LeBron, Wade, Bosh, Carmelo — 60 selections and counting. 2000 gave it one Sixth Man of the Year, one All-Star center who averaged 13.6 that season, and a second-round pick from Ohio State who had to become great on his own.
Every franchise that lost that year lost to a coin flip, not a plan. And the league has spent twenty-five years using that class as the cautionary tale every time someone promises that the draft will save them.