⌕

THE THEFT WAS THE SMALL NUMBER

NOV 14, 2026 · SPLASH · MONEY · THE ASSET
WWF New York Times Square restaurant $24.5 million 2000 The World WWE impairment $32.9 million Kenton Jenkins grand larceny $437,000 CSG Construction

THE ASSET. $24.5 million for 46,500 square feet of Times Square. A $437,000 arrest everybody remembers, and a $32.9 million write-down nobody does.

MAY 2000. THE WWF BOUGHT A RESTAURANT IN TIMES SQUARE FOR $24.5 MILLION.

It was 46,500 square feet at the corner of Broadway and 43rd, license plates deep in the Paramount Theatre building — a restaurant, a nightclub, an arcade, a merchandise store, a small theater, and a television set, because Sunday Night Heat was often broadcast from there.

The company projected it would do $20 million to $25 million in its first full year under its ownership.

Thirty-three months later it was gone, and the write-down was $32.9 million.

AND THE THING EVERYBODY REMEMBERS IS THE SCANDAL — WHICH WAS, IN DOLLARS, THE SMALLEST PART OF THE STORY.

In September 2002, somebody looking through the books found transactions that didn't make sense. WWE brought in forensic accountants. According to reporting at the time, the trail led to Kenton Jenkins, 39, of Demarest, New Jersey — the man the company had hired in May 2000 to run the place.

The allegation: that he wrote roughly $437,000 in company checks to a construction company that did not exist, and then created paperwork to cover it. He had already been fired in June 2002.

On November 8, 2002, he was arrested at his home and charged with four counts of grand larceny — three in the second degree and one in the third. He had been earning $195,000 a year. If convicted of the most serious count, he faced up to 15 years.

AN ARREST IS AN ACCUSATION, NOT A FINDING. WWE also sued him in civil court that month. And here is the part the video leaves out, because I don't think anybody knows it: I could not find a record of how the criminal case ended. No plea, no verdict, no dismissal — nothing after November 2002 in anything I could reach. So this page does not say he was convicted, because I don't know that, and neither does the video.

A NAME THE VIDEO GETS WRONG
The narration calls him "Kitten Jenkins." That appears to be a transcription artifact. The man arrested in this case, in the reporting from the New York Times, the New York Post, the Daily News and MarketWatch, is Kenton Jenkins. The detail the video does get right is the dollar figure: about $437,000 in checks to a company that didn't exist.

Getting a name wrong in a story about an accusation is not a small thing. That's why the correction is up here and not at the bottom.

NOW LOOK AT THAT NUMBER NEXT TO THE OTHER ONES.

The alleged theft: $437,000. The operating loss WWE reported for fiscal 2003: about $43.1 million.

That's about one percent. The embezzlement wasn't the reason the restaurant failed. It was a rounding error with a mugshot attached — which is exactly why it's the part people remember.

SO LET'S DO THE REST OF THE ARITHMETIC, BECAUSE IT'S BRUTAL AND NOBODY EVER RUNS IT.

In its own annual report for the year ended April 30, 2002, WWE disclosed that it had paid $24.5 million for the leased 46,500 square foot complex in May 2000 — and had already invested an additional $16.0 million in it by then. That's over $40 million in the building before the first full year was even closed out.

Year one under company ownership: revenue of $16.6 million, a loss of about $200,000. Short of the $20–25 million projection, but close enough to keep going.

Year two: revenue fell to $14.1 million, and the loss jumped to roughly $7.9 million.

Meanwhile the world around it changed. The Attitude Era boom the place opened into was over. WCW was gone. Steve Austin walked out. In 2002 the company renamed itself WWE after losing a legal fight with the World Wildlife Fund, and the giant logo on the building came down. WWF New York became The World — and the numbers didn't change with the sign.

FEBRUARY 25, 2003. WWE ANNOUNCED IT WAS CLOSING.

The restaurant and nightclub shut that day. The retail store stayed open until April 27, 2003.

The accounting that followed is the real story of the venture: WWE recorded an impairment charge of $32.9 million on The World — $20.4 million of it after tax — plus a charge for estimated shutdown costs of about $8.9 million after tax. The fiscal year showed $8.1 million in revenue and an operating loss of roughly $43.1 million.

And the company couldn't just lock the door. WWE still had the lease, and it ran through October 2017 — so for years afterward the company was trying to sublease a failed restaurant or pay for one it wasn't using. The space eventually became a Hard Rock Cafe.

WHO ACTUALLY PULLED THE PLUG? TWO DIFFERENT ANSWERS, AND ONLY ONE IS DOCUMENTED.

The record says Linda McMahon, then WWE's chief executive, made the decision to close the restaurant and nightclub in February 2003 so the company could focus on its global business. That's how the company announced it and how it has been reported since.

JBL has said over the years that the manager stealing money was what finally made Vince McMahon fed up enough to shut it down. That's a colorful and plausible story, and it is a claim by one person, not the company's account.

Both can be true at once — a CEO can close a business that a theft made intolerable. But only one of them shows up in a press release.

SPLASH'S READ: Here's the thing this page is actually about, and it's the same argument as every other story in this cluster.

The WWF didn't lose because somebody stole $437,000. It lost because it bought an operating business at the exact top of a boom, with a lease that outlived the boom by fourteen years.

The brand survived all of it. WWE is still here, worth billions, and the company that wrote off a Times Square restaurant is the same company that later signed a five-billion-dollar deal with Netflix and got bought into a media conglomerate. Nothing about the restaurant touched the asset, because the restaurant was never the asset.

That's the distinction that runs through this whole site: Vienna Beef's sign was the asset; the stands were other people's risk. Jesse Cole owns the league and the other dugout. Hank Aaron lost his savings on a loan and rebuilt on franchises. An NFL owner buys a seat, not a product.

The World was a product — 46,500 square feet of rent, staff, inventory and a concept that depended on a boom continuing. The boom ended, and the lease didn't.

A restaurant with a $24.5 million price tag, a $437,000 scandal, and a $32.9 million write-down, all inside thirty-three months. The scandal is the story people tell. The lease is the reason it happened.

Sources & claims: SOURCES, CLAIM BY CLAIM — The purchase: WWF New York opened in November 1999 under an outside group licensing the WWF name, and in May 2000 World Wrestling Federation Entertainment acquired the leased 46,500 square foot entertainment complex in Times Square for approximately $24.5 million, disclosing in its annual report for the fiscal year ended 30 April 2002 that it had invested an additional $16.0 million in the facility by that date. The company projected first-full-year revenue of $20 million to $25 million when it announced the acquisition. The results: the operation generated $16.6 million in its first full fiscal year under company ownership against a loss of about $200,000, and $14.1 million with a loss of about $7.9 million in the following year. In February 2003 the company announced the closure of the restaurant and nightclub effective immediately, with the retail store closing on 27 April 2003, and reported an impairment charge of $32.9 million ($20.4 million after tax) together with approximately $8.9 million after tax in estimated shutdown costs. Fiscal 2003 revenue was about $8.1 million with an operating loss of approximately $43.1 million. The lease on the space ran through October 2017 and the site later became a Hard Rock Cafe. The figure of $12.1 million in shutdown costs cited in the source video differs from the company's reported $8.9 million after-tax charge, and this page uses the company's figure. The accusation: in September 2002 WWE identified what it described as suspicious financial transactions connected to the complex and retained forensic accountants; in November 2002 the company reported that Kenton Jenkins, 39, of Demarest, New Jersey — hired in May 2000 at a salary reported at $195,000 and fired in June 2002 — had been arrested and charged with four counts of grand larceny, three in the second degree and one in the third, over approximately $437,000 in company checks written to a company called CSG Construction that did not exist, for work that was never performed, with paperwork allegedly created to disguise it. The Manhattan district attorney's office handled the matter and WWE filed a civil action that month. AN ARREST AND A CHARGE ARE ACCUSATIONS, NOT FINDINGS OF GUILT. This page could not locate any record of the disposition of the criminal case — no plea, verdict or dismissal appears in the accessible reporting after November 2002 — and therefore states no conclusion about his guilt, makes no finding, and does not repeat the secondary claims about how the money was spent. The name correction: the source video's narration renders the name as 'Kitten Jenkins'; contemporaneous reporting in The New York Times, the New York Post, the New York Daily News and MarketWatch identifies him as Kenton Jenkins. The closure: the decision to close was announced by World Wrestling Entertainment in February 2003, with Linda McMahon then serving as chief executive; JBL's account that the theft prompted Vince McMahon to shut the facility is a claim attributed to him and is presented as such, not as the company's stated reason. The analysis of operating risk versus brand value, and the comparison to other ownership arrangements covered on this site, is this piece's own. Source video: The WWF New York Embezzlement Scandal (Pinfalls & Pixels, 5 November 2026) — used as the prompt; the purchase price, square footage, revenue and loss figures, impairment and shutdown charges, closure dates, lease term and arrest details above were checked against WWE's own annual report and press releases, and contemporaneous reporting in The New York Times, the New York Post, the New York Daily News, Broadcasting & Cable and MarketWatch.