THE AWARD. Nine days of hearings, a $9.8 million repayment order, $625,000 to a church — and a ruling that the man called majority owner isn't.
THE NUMBER. A panel of three arbitrators ordered Zeus Network CEO Lemuel Plummer to pay the company back $9,826,837. With legal fees, interest and costs, his co-founders are asking a court to confirm $13,779,781.25 — plus 8.25% simple interest on the damages.
And it is not yet a court judgment. It's an arbitration award, which became public when the co-founders filed to confirm it in Los Angeles Superior Court on September 29, 2026. Plummer disputes the public narrative and calls it misleading.
WHAT THE PANEL FOUND. After nine days of hearings in July and August 2025, three arbitrators — William D. Johnson, Steven J. Kaine and Glenn J. Waldman — concluded Plummer had treated the company account as an extension of himself:
Unapproved compensation paid to himself as CEO and manager.
$625,000 sent to a church led by his father — which the panel characterized as misappropriation of funds.
Millions moved through payment apps and cash withdrawals with little or no documentation.
On top of the repayment, he was ordered to cover 75% of the arbitrators' and AAA's fees, and to reimburse Zeus for the legal costs of defending him.
WHERE ZEUS CAME FROM. The network launched on July 13, 2018 with four co-founders: Lemuel Plummer, DeStorm Power, King Bach (Andrew Bachelor) and Amanda Cerny.
The structure mattered more than anyone realized at the time. Plummer became CEO and manager — the person who ran the money. And the company's own operating agreement required disputes to go to arbitration, not to a courtroom.
That clause is why this story stayed invisible for years. Arbitration is private. There is no docket, no press row, no public filing — until somebody asks a judge to enforce the result.
THE TIMELINE.
October 2022: King Bach (through Batch Enterprises), Amanda Cerny and DeStorm Power demand arbitration through the American Arbitration Association.
July–August 2025: nine days of hearings.
December 2025: the panel rules on who actually owns the company.
April 24, 2026: the final award issues — and stays sealed in practice, because arbitration awards aren't published.
September 29, 2026: the co-founders file in LA Superior Court to convert the award into an enforceable judgment. That's the day it became a story.
THE PART THAT GOT BURIED. The headlines said the CEO got caught. The more consequential finding was about ownership.
For years, Plummer was described — including by himself — as the majority owner of Zeus. The arbitration panel upheld 16% stakes for each of the three co-founders, which means the man who has been publicly framed as the controlling owner isn't the majority owner the way the story was told.
And 16% of a company that Plummer has valued in the hundreds of millions is not a symbolic number. Reporting on the award put the three co-founders' combined stakes at a potential $480 million — a figure derived from Plummer's own valuation claims, not from an independent appraisal.
So the real dispute was never about $9.8 million. It was about who owns the asset the $9.8 million was taken out of.
HIS SIDE. Plummer responded with a six-slide statement posted to his and the network's Instagram, calling the public narrative "inaccurate and misleading."
His version: the co-founders walked away with $1 each in nominal damages — symbolic awards, not a personal payday. And on that narrow point he's literally correct: the panel issued three separate $1 nominal damages awards to the co-founders jointly, because the money at issue was ordered back to the company, not to them personally.
But "$1" and "nothing happened" are not the same sentence. The panel also upheld their ownership stakes, ordered a nine-figure-scale repayment into the company they partly own, and made Plummer pay the fees. A nominal dollar on the personal claim is what an arbitration award looks like when the entity — not the individual — is the injured party.
WHAT THIS SAYS ABOUT THE CREATOR-ECONOMY BUSINESS MODEL. Zeus is a Black-owned streaming network built on reality programming — Baddies, Joseline's Cabaret — and it exists because a founder with a distribution idea and three creators with audiences decided to build something together.
That arrangement has a predictable failure mode, and it isn't unique to Zeus:
1. The creator brings the audience; the operator brings the structure. The operator controls the bank account, the contracts and the information. The creators control attention — which is the revenue — but they see the books last, if at all.
2. The operating agreement is the whole ballgame. An arbitration clause and a manager with sole signature authority is a structure that works beautifully until the relationship sours — and then it determines everything about who can find out what.
3. Equity is worthless if you can't see the ledger. A 16% stake is a fortune or a fiction depending on accounting you don't control. This is the fight every creator-owned company eventually has.
SPLASH'S READ: The $9.8 million is the number that travels. The ownership ruling is the one that matters — because it converted three creators from people who were told they were minority partners into people with a documented claim on a company they helped build.
And the mechanism is worth remembering: they didn't win in public. They won in a private arbitration room, nine days of hearings, and then walked into a courthouse to make it real.
The loudest part of this story isn't the money. It's that it took four years and a court filing for anybody to hear about it.