THE PREMISE: The host opens with a simple truth: ever since the ancient Greeks started the Olympics, human nature has always found a way to cheat in sports. Once large amounts of money hit the picture in the 20th century, the temptation got too big, and cheating became a daily operation worldwide. The countdown: 10 athletes who thought they would get away with fraud — and got caught and humiliated instead.
PINEDA'S PINE TAR: First up and closest to home: Michael Pineda, the Dominican pitcher, back in 2014 when he wore Yankees pinstripes. Pine tar on the mound was illegal but not severely penalized, and plenty of pitchers around the league used it — the tar gives the ball a better grip without losing any speed. Pineda's mistake wasn't doing it. It was how obvious he'd been about it. On a cold, windy night at Fenway Park against the Red Sox, he figured he needed a lot of pine to throw properly — so he applied a lot of it right on his neck, then from his neck to the ball. The officials didn't need a replay:
"It was clear as day what he was doing."
Pineda got tossed immediately and hit with a 10-game suspension — for doing something everybody else did too, except the rest were a little smarter about not making it blatantly obvious.
SOSA'S CORKED BAT: A corked bat is a bat hollowed out and filled with cork or other less dense material to make it lighter — quicker swing, better timing for the hitter. In 2003, Sammy Sosa was playing for the Cubs against Tampa Bay when he shattered his bat in the first inning. No big deal — it happens all the time, grab another bat, game resumes. Except the plate umpire noticed pieces of cork among the shards and ejected Sosa on the spot. Sosa owned the bat, explaining he occasionally used it for batting practice and home run exhibitions to entertain his fans. MLB confiscated and tested 76 of his other bats after the ejection — all clean, no cork. Didn't matter. The crime had been committed, and Sosa still served a seven-game suspension.
LOADED GLOVES & A FAKE MARATHON: Boxing's Antonio Margarito was supposed to fight Shane Mosley for the WBA welterweight title in 2009 — until Mosley's trainer noticed Margarito's hands were wrapped strangely and asked for the tape to be examined. The coach's eye was right: when the wraps were cut off, officials found small knuckle pads made of plaster, the stuff casts are made of, meant to add damage to every punch. Margarito claimed he was unaware, his coach took the blame, he re-wrapped and went on to lose the fight and the title to Mosley — then both he and his coach got suspended from boxing in the U.S. for one year. Then there's Rosie Ruiz, who "won" the 1980 Boston Marathon with an official time of 2:31:56 — the third-fastest women's time ever run at that point. Spectators came forward saying they saw her join the race about half a mile from the finish line. She never appeared in any photos or footage of the race. The title got stripped. She got no further penalties.
THE HAND OF GOD: Diego Maradona scored two of his most famous goals in the same 1986 World Cup quarterfinal against England. The second was a stunner — picking the ball up in his own half and dribbling past every defender and the goalkeeper. The first was genius too, in an entirely different way: with the deflected ball heading into the England keeper's hands, the 5'5" Maradona somehow got there first and flicked it into the net with his hand. The ref missed it, Argentina advanced, and Diego kept the post-game interview cheeky:
"If it really was a handball, it was a hand of god."
ARMSTRONG'S EPO: "Pane e acqua" — Italian for bread and water — is cycling slang for riding clean. Lance Armstrong rode on bread and water through the early 90s: talented without a doubt, but not achieving anything extraordinary. After beating testicular cancer, he returned in 1998 and wasn't fueling on bread and water anymore. He was on EPO, which stimulates red blood cell production and puts more oxygen in the blood — more oxygen, more endurance. Seven straight Tour de France titles followed. Insiders knew he was cheating; he never failed a drug test, which he gladly repeated in nearly every interview. It took a massive 2013 USADA investigation and testimony from former teammates to finally force the admission.
THE REST OF THE RAP SHEET: Dwight Howard caught in 2016 with a can of Stickum visible on the Rockets' bench — the spray is illegal in the NBA and NFL, but neither Howard nor Houston was penalized. Tonya Harding, after an FBI investigation into her bodyguard and ex-husband, eventually pleaded guilty over the attack on Nancy Kerrigan: three years probation, a $160,000 fine, and banned from skating forever. Mike Tyson bit a piece out of Evander Holyfield's ear in their 1997 rematch and got disqualified — the beginning of the end of his storied career. And Tom Brady's Deflategate: 11 of 12 Patriots balls measured about 1.5 pounds of pressure below the minimum in the 2014 AFC Championship; Brady got four games, and the Pats got fined millions and forfeited two draft picks.
SPLASH'S READ: Pineda didn't catch 10 games for cheating — he caught 10 games for being stupid, because half the league had a shiny neck that decade and knew how to keep it subtle. Sosa's 76 clean bats tell you more than the one that cracked: he knew exactly which bat to bring, and that's called having a system. Fraud don't end careers — getting caught sloppy does. The ones still holding trophies just never got sloppy.