THE HISTORY. Tariffs, liquor and land paid for the country until a Supreme Court ruling, a constitutional amendment and two world wars changed everything.
THE SHORT ANSWER. Before 1913, the United States government ran on three engines: tariffs on imports, excise taxes on things like liquor and tobacco, and sales of public land.
For most of the nineteenth century, customs duties were the single largest source of federal revenue — roughly half of receipts in many years. The country was financed by taxing goods as they crossed the border, not by taxing what people earned.
That worked because the government was tiny. No standing army of the size we have now, no Social Security, no Medicare, no federal role in education or health. A tariff state and a small state were the same thing.
THE FIRST ATTEMPTS AT AN INCOME TAX. The idea isn't new — it's older than the country's modern form.
1861: to pay for the Civil War, Congress passes the first federal income tax. It's temporary, and it's repealed in 1872.
1894: Congress tries again in the Wilson–Gorman Tariff Act, adding a 2% tax on incomes above $4,000.
1895: the Supreme Court kills it — Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. — holding that a tax on income from property is a direct tax, which the Constitution requires to be apportioned among the states by population. That's impossible to do with an income tax, so the tax was dead.
Eighteen years of nothing. The country was financed by tariffs and excise taxes, and the Supreme Court had said the alternative was unconstitutional.
1913 — THE AMENDMENT. The Sixteenth Amendment was ratified on February 3, 1913, giving Congress the power to tax incomes "from whatever source derived" without apportionment.
The Revenue Act of 1913 followed that year — the first permanent federal income tax since 1872.
And look at what it actually was: a top marginal rate of 7%, applied to incomes above $500,000 — an enormous sum in 1913. Only a tiny fraction of Americans paid anything at all.
The income tax was sold as a tax on the rich. For its first several years, it was exactly that.
THE WAR THAT MADE IT A MASS TAX. Then the numbers moved fast:
1918: the top rate hits 77% to pay for World War I.
1944: the top rate reaches 94% to pay for World War II — and, more importantly, the tax base goes from "rich people" to almost everybody.
1943: the Current Tax Payment Act introduces withholding — taxes taken out of each paycheck before you ever see the money.
That's the invention that made the income tax permanent. A tax you pay once a year is a political event. A tax you never see is a fact of nature.
WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM NOW. The modern federal government is financed overwhelmingly by taxes on income and work:
Individual income taxes — roughly half of federal receipts.
Payroll taxes for Social Security and Medicare — roughly a third.
Corporate income taxes — around a tenth.
Customs duties — historically a sliver, a couple of percent.
The engine that built the country got demoted to a rounding error.
AND THEN, IN 2026, THE TARIFF ENGINE CAME BACK — AND GOT SWITCHED OFF. The Trump administration imposed sweeping tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. Customs collections surged. Tariffs briefly mattered again.
On February 20, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump and Trump v. V.O.S. Selections, Inc. that IEEPA does not authorize the President to impose tariffs. The "reciprocal" tariffs and the other IEEPA duties were invalidated.
What happened next is the most extraordinary fiscal fact of the year:
More than $175 billion in collected duties became subject to refunds. By August 5, 2026, the government had refunded about $100 billion. Importers were on track for roughly $166 billion back.
And for three months in 2026, customs refunds outran customs receipts — the government was paying out more in tariff money than it was taking in.
Net customs duties for fiscal 2026 came to about $172 billion, according to the Congressional Budget Office — with the projection cut by roughly $250 billion after the ruling.
WHY THE CHOICE OF TAX IS A CHOICE ABOUT WHO PAYS. This is the part that matters more than any single rate:
A tariff is a tax on imports — paid at the border, passed into prices, and felt most by the people who spend the largest share of their income on goods. It's regressive by construction.
An income tax is a tax on earnings — and with a progressive rate structure, it can be designed so the people with the most income pay the highest share. It's progressive by construction.
The country ran for 140 years on the first model and 110 on the second, and the switch wasn't driven by economics. It was driven by a constitutional ruling, a war, and the invention of payroll withholding.
SPLASH'S READ: The United States didn't have no taxes before 1913. It had a completely different tax system — one that fell on goods, land and imports, ran a government a fraction of today's size, and was ended not by a vote but by an amendment forced by a Supreme Court decision.
And 2026 just proved the old system can be turned back on and off: $175 billion collected, then refunded, because five justices read a 1977 statute differently than the executive did.
Tax policy is not a dial. It's a legal architecture — and the whole thing can move at once.