THE SETUP: On April 21, 2025, news broke that Pope Francis, Bishop of Rome, had passed away. Millions across the world mourned the head of the Catholic Church — while, as Baseball Doesn't Exist tells it, almost simultaneously thousands, if not millions, flocked to the sportsbooks to bet that Phillies slugger Nick Castellanos was about to hit a home run. A game against the Mets was hours away, and the books knew that night could be one of the most profitable — or most expensive — in the legalized betting era.
THE MEME: Castellanos didn't become the tragedy bet on accident. The host runs the résumé: his first professional home run in 2011 landed the same day Osama bin Laden was killed. In 2020, Reds broadcaster Thom Brennaman was caught on a hot mic dropping a slur mid-apology — and as he told the audience he thought of himself as a man of faith, Castellanos interrupted him with a bomb. That call became a copy-paste meme tweeted over 7,000 times in a month. Then the hits kept landing on bad days: a Royals tribute to a 96-year-old WWII veteran, a Memorial Day tribute to fallen soldiers, the night Will Smith slapped Chris Rock, the I-95 collapse, news of Charlie Manuel's stroke, and a walk-off double 30 minutes after Willie Mays died. Even Castellanos' wife tried to shut it down — "Something happens every day in the world. Find a new joke" — and the trolling drowned her out.
"there's a drive in a deep left field by Castanos. It will be a home run."
"Honestly, it's ridiculous how you all find pleasure in such horrific and terrible events." — Nick Castellanos' brother, replying to the meme accounts
THE BIDEN WARMUP: July 2024 was the dress rehearsal. When Joe Biden dropped out of the presidential race, bettors rushed the books on Castellanos, and FanDuel limited how much anyone could put on him — the books knew they were at extreme risk. He homered that night anyway, and hundreds, if not thousands, of winning slips flooded social media. The host calls it a massive loss for the books — and "the best thing that could ever happen to them," because now betting on Castellanos after a tragedy was itself the meme.
THE POPE NIGHT: April 21, 2025 was the climax, and this time the books were prepared. Per Google Trends, the Pope's passing brought Castellanos close to three times the attention of the Biden moment — meaning three times the money and three times the risk. Before the news spread, he was listed as high as +775 to homer; the books were essentially saying he had an 8% chance. Once the news hit, the line moved as low as +425 — a jump from an implied 8% to 20% "just because the Pope passed away."
THE BET: The matchup said stay away. Castellanos faced a pitcher with a 1.09 ERA who hadn't given up a home run all year — the 11th hardest pitcher to homer against in the National League — in 46° weather with the wind blowing in. It did not matter at all. On a day the Premier League, NHL playoffs and NBA playoffs were all running, a Castellanos homer was the most popular bet of the night, drawing three times more action than any other player. And 97% of bettors took him to homer — one of the most lopsided books possible, and somehow the most popular. The books held the edge on price, but a Castellanos bomb would still have cost them an ungodly amount.
THE GAME: Castellanos went 0-for-4. Strikeout looking in the second. Strikeout on three pitches in the fourth. Pop out in the sixth. Then the eighth inning — his last shot, wind now blowing out to right, four homers already on the board in the game. Down 0-2, he connected, and for a split second it looked like the meme had done it again. It was caught. Bettors went home disappointed, and the sportsbooks walked away with millions.
SPLASH'S READ: A man of God leaves this earth, and within the hour half the country ran to the window like the funeral was a parlay. The books watched the meme build, moved the number, and swept millions off a man going 0-for-4. Respect to the faithful and to the man they lost — but nobody ever made money betting on tragedy. The house already knows how the story ends.